{
  "version": "NP176-SCIENTIFIC-METHOD-1",
  "status": "ACTIVE",
  "principle": "conclusions follow reproducible evidence; every empirical claim must be exposed to possible falsification",
  "claim_required_fields": [
    "exact_claim",
    "claim_type",
    "system_boundary",
    "numerator",
    "denominator",
    "energy_stage",
    "region",
    "period",
    "units",
    "aggregation_rule",
    "primary_source",
    "extraction_or_calculation",
    "falsifier",
    "alternatives",
    "uncertainty",
    "status",
    "evidence"
  ],
  "status_vocabulary": [
    "PASS",
    "FAIL",
    "UNKNOWN",
    "NOT_APPLICABLE"
  ],
  "review_separation": [
    "technical_correctness",
    "scientific_validity"
  ],
  "deepseek_review": {
    "role": "adversarial secondary reviewer",
    "desired_verdict_prohibited": true,
    "inherit_previous_pass": false,
    "minimum_disproof_paths": 3,
    "must_check_primary_sources": true,
    "must_report_unchecked_scope": true,
    "model_agreement_is_evidence": false
  },
  "release_gate": [
    "claim_card_complete",
    "source_chain_verified",
    "falsification_attempt_recorded",
    "boundary_visible_near_number",
    "technical_test_pass",
    "scientific_review_pass"
  ],
  "document": "C:\\Users\\press\\Documents\\Codex\\01_00.000_НП\\01_04.190_НП_РИД_НАУЧНЫЕ_НАПРАВЛЕНИЯ\\01_04.192_НП_ЭНЕРГОБАЛАНС_ПРОТОКОЛ_НАУЧНОЙ_ПРОВЕРКИ.md"
}