{
  "schema_version": 3,
  "build_content_version": "NP176-FINAL-frozen",
  "complete_claim_registry": true,
  "annual_forecast": null,
  "national_dataset_used": false,
  "records": [
    {
      "id": "D01",
      "statement": "Годовой конечная стадия EROI мирового ископаемого энергомикса",
      "value": [
        9.588220725334994,
        9.474943148967688,
        9.260692468611749,
        9.194785699748738,
        9.420250086466329,
        9.662970005438117,
        9.670927381673195,
        9.598866557054997,
        9.815165092831753,
        9.39968671461533,
        9.359215296982676,
        8.99710953420679,
        8.986214698895527,
        9.029974176072429,
        8.715180527776424,
        8.744164132084254,
        8.667775710161399,
        8.663890735994315,
        8.503477161518205,
        9.008494578988469,
        9.02238356712874,
        8.800811901561458,
        8.608452700357716,
        8.5364542725521,
        8.75757270009215,
        8.752278784257982,
        8.543227831098633,
        8.357148618720435,
        8.443995721438199,
        8.476272657426597,
        8.476403772581296,
        8.484202179473781,
        8.468316540708724,
        8.673374979786066,
        8.371942446198346,
        8.200859128011784,
        8.085267317610981,
        8.01964234670508,
        8.067539094128074,
        7.935926000780805,
        7.854624029440081,
        8.0121359555981,
        7.868332266959073,
        8.45291851150937,
        8.517765193521496,
        8.513315290070206,
        8.542499011395632,
        8.551028787713516,
        8.353664797536403,
        8.469450668855734
      ],
      "unit": "безразмерное отношение",
      "period": [
        1971,
        2020
      ],
      "region": "мир (WRLD)",
      "status": "опубликованная модельная оценка",
      "source_url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41560-024-01518-6",
      "source_locator": "Fig. 2; released dataset file 46240243; row Final (fuel+elec+heat) / All fossil fuels / Included",
      "source_version": "Nature Energy 2024; Figshare version 1",
      "access_date": "2026-09-14",
      "transformation": "Широкая CSV-строка развёрнута в 50 годовых ячеек; округление до 0,001 только в HTML; без интерполяции и экстраполяции",
      "data_file": "eroi-history-data.json",
      "source_file": "source_cache/figshare_46240243_global_erois.csv",
      "source_sha256": "12241f109b0e1f540f591fbaec912961ea0b458365a029f7dae5396cfd10340d",
      "numerator": "конечная энергия, доставленная потребителю",
      "denominator": "конечная энергия, вложенная в отрасль ископаемого топлива",
      "indirect_energy": "Included",
      "capital_energy": "Excluded",
      "source_kind": "external_primary_or_official",
      "source_reference": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41560-024-01518-6",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "local_hash_and_row_locator_rechecked",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "Figshare released CSV row: Final / All fossil fuels / Included",
        "sha256": "12241f109b0e1f540f591fbaec912961ea0b458365a029f7dae5396cfd10340d",
        "local_evidence_file": "source_cache/figshare_46240243_global_erois.csv"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "D02",
      "statement": "Годовой полезная стадия EROI мирового ископаемого энергомикса",
      "value": [
        2.9386874133123175,
        2.906789921187228,
        2.8517806541402804,
        2.8392219753058088,
        2.908071553049592,
        3.006931743710443,
        3.0320549625966025,
        3.0180617787351833,
        3.124454417512143,
        3.0330327091859277,
        3.0360903926462552,
        2.9349756280470305,
        2.9465829973264115,
        3.0052015374491416,
        2.9130139253879923,
        2.933903653628395,
        2.931849690528442,
        2.9592061880050724,
        2.924339373309705,
        3.149402815780076,
        3.195981262166562,
        3.1262665233120397,
        3.0857957145724133,
        3.063440365682765,
        3.1177241882799955,
        3.1576057667830004,
        3.13439153904784,
        3.0919612610077483,
        3.102210890605607,
        3.1380809137833325,
        3.13552234848438,
        3.132255457376764,
        3.194461051743174,
        3.2491703184186678,
        3.170416146377521,
        3.130147368990194,
        3.083663449413848,
        3.108105388194911,
        3.1743123421818917,
        3.1517048390824263,
        3.188614634464301,
        3.274631123958015,
        3.1965662847541667,
        3.408812907418552,
        3.4194434173899313,
        3.3872943105360025,
        3.4067143820092918,
        3.4585633570662835,
        3.37828394213831,
        3.4783450451745317
      ],
      "unit": "безразмерное отношение",
      "period": [
        1971,
        2020
      ],
      "region": "мир (WRLD)",
      "status": "опубликованная модельная оценка",
      "source_url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41560-024-01518-6",
      "source_locator": "Fig. 2; released dataset file 46240243; row Useful (fuel+elec+heat) / All fossil fuels / Included",
      "source_version": "Nature Energy 2024; Figshare version 1",
      "access_date": "2026-09-14",
      "transformation": "Широкая CSV-строка развёрнута в 50 годовых ячеек; округление до 0,001 только в HTML; без интерполяции и экстраполяции",
      "data_file": "eroi-history-data.json",
      "source_file": "source_cache/figshare_46240243_global_erois.csv",
      "source_sha256": "12241f109b0e1f540f591fbaec912961ea0b458365a029f7dae5396cfd10340d",
      "numerator": "полезная энергия после конечного устройства",
      "denominator": "конечная энергия, вложенная в отрасль ископаемого топлива",
      "indirect_energy": "Included",
      "capital_energy": "Excluded",
      "source_kind": "external_primary_or_official",
      "source_reference": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41560-024-01518-6",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "local_hash_and_row_locator_rechecked",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "Figshare released CSV row: Useful / All fossil fuels / Included",
        "sha256": "12241f109b0e1f540f591fbaec912961ea0b458365a029f7dae5396cfd10340d",
        "local_evidence_file": "source_cache/figshare_46240243_global_erois.csv"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "D03",
      "statement": "Сети: ориентир реализации COP28",
      "value": 25,
      "unit": "млн км новых или обновлённых сетей",
      "period": 2030,
      "region": "мир",
      "status": "условный ориентир",
      "source_url": "https://www.iea.org/reports/from-taking-stock-to-taking-action/executive-summary",
      "source_locator": "Key benchmarks for energy system transitions aligned with the COP28 outcome",
      "source_version": "2024",
      "access_date": "2026-09-13",
      "transformation": "Перенос ориентира; не фактический ввод",
      "source_kind": "external_primary_or_official",
      "source_reference": "https://www.iea.org/reports/from-taking-stock-to-taking-action/executive-summary",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "official_web_text_reopened",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "IEA executive summary: more than 25 million km of grids by 2030"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "D04",
      "statement": "Мощность накопителей: ориентир COP28",
      "value": 1500,
      "unit": "ГВт",
      "period": 2030,
      "region": "мир",
      "status": "условный ориентир",
      "source_url": "https://www.iea.org/reports/from-taking-stock-to-taking-action/executive-summary",
      "source_locator": "Without grids and storage, the tripling of renewables will not succeed",
      "source_version": "2024",
      "access_date": "2026-09-13",
      "transformation": "Мощность; не ГВт·ч и не длительность хранения",
      "source_kind": "external_primary_or_official",
      "source_reference": "https://www.iea.org/reports/from-taking-stock-to-taking-action/executive-summary",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "official_web_text_reopened",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "IEA executive summary: 1 500 GW of storage capacity by 2030"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "D05",
      "statement": "Сети для национальных целей",
      "value": ">80",
      "unit": "млн км новых или обновлённых сетей",
      "period": 2040,
      "region": "мир",
      "status": "условный ориентир",
      "source_url": "https://www.iea.org/reports/electricity-grids-and-secure-energy-transitions/executive-summary",
      "source_locator": "Reaching national goals also means adding or refurbishing a total of over 80 million kilometres of grids by 2040",
      "source_version": "2023",
      "access_date": "2026-09-13",
      "transformation": "Не складывать с ориентиром 2030: разные публикации и горизонты",
      "source_kind": "external_primary_or_official",
      "source_reference": "https://www.iea.org/reports/electricity-grids-and-secure-energy-transitions/executive-summary",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "official_web_text_reopened",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "IEA executive summary: over 80 million km added or refurbished by 2040"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "D06",
      "statement": "Численность населения: ранняя округлённая сводка",
      "value": [
        8.2,
        8.5,
        9.6
      ],
      "unit": "млрд человек",
      "period": [
        2024,
        2030,
        2050
      ],
      "region": "мир",
      "status": "сохранённая запись прошлой итерации; для таблицы I9 не используется",
      "source_url": "https://population.un.org/wpp/",
      "source_locator": "WPP 2024 summary; exact regional cells are recorded in D14",
      "source_version": "2024",
      "access_date": "2026-09-13",
      "transformation": "Округлённая сводка сохранена для истории; не смешивать с точным извлечением D14",
      "source_kind": "external_primary_or_official",
      "source_reference": "https://population.un.org/wpp/",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "archived_not_used_not_revalidated",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "Historical rounded record; excluded from current calculations; exact D14 cells supersede it"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "D07",
      "statement": "Энергия реакции D+T",
      "value": 17.6,
      "unit": "МэВ",
      "period": "одна реакция",
      "region": "не географическая величина",
      "status": "физическая величина",
      "source_url": "https://www.iter.org/node/20687/magic-cocktail-deuterium-and-tritium",
      "source_locator": "The magic cocktail of deuterium and tritium",
      "source_version": "страница ITER",
      "access_date": "2026-09-13",
      "transformation": "Округление; не электрический выход всей установки",
      "source_kind": "external_primary_or_official",
      "source_reference": "https://www.iter.org/node/20687/magic-cocktail-deuterium-and-tritium",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "official_web_text_reopened",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "ITER page states 17.6 MeV for one D-T reaction"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "M01",
      "statement": "Учебный диапазон EROI",
      "value": [
        100,
        5
      ],
      "unit": "безразмерное отношение",
      "period": "один условный расчётный год",
      "region": "одно условное хозяйство",
      "status": "учебное условие",
      "source_url": null,
      "source_locator": "#explore",
      "source_version": "v4",
      "access_date": null,
      "transformation": "Выбранный диапазон; не наблюдение и не годовой ряд",
      "source_kind": "internal_project_rule",
      "source_reference": "#explore",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "internal_rule_reproducible_I24",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "#explore"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "M02",
      "statement": "Арифметика шкалы",
      "value": [
        1,
        5,
        20,
        99,
        95,
        80
      ],
      "unit": "% валового выхода",
      "period": "один условный расчётный год",
      "region": "одно условное хозяйство",
      "status": "учебный расчёт",
      "source_url": null,
      "source_locator": "#aggregation; app.js updateEROI",
      "source_version": "v3",
      "access_date": null,
      "transformation": "Затраты=100/R, остаток=100−100/R; R=100/20/5",
      "source_kind": "internal_project_rule",
      "source_reference": "#aggregation; app.js updateEROI",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "internal_rule_reproducible_I24",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "#aggregation; app.js updateEROI"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "M03",
      "statement": "Окно устойчивого снижения",
      "value": 3,
      "unit": "годовых изменения",
      "period": "T−3…T",
      "region": "мир, учебные ответы",
      "status": "проектное правило",
      "source_url": null,
      "source_locator": "#scenario-contract",
      "source_version": "scenario-v5",
      "access_date": null,
      "transformation": "Три сравнения между четырьмя годовыми наблюдениями T−3…T; проектное правило без статистически оценённого порога.",
      "source_kind": "internal_project_rule",
      "source_reference": "#scenario-contract",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "internal_rule_reproducible_I24",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "#scenario-contract"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "M04",
      "statement": "Горизонт календаря",
      "value": [
        2026,
        2050
      ],
      "unit": "год",
      "period": "2026–2050",
      "region": "мир",
      "status": "проектный горизонт",
      "source_url": null,
      "source_locator": "#milestones",
      "source_version": "v3",
      "access_date": null,
      "transformation": "Выбор вех; не вычисляет EROI",
      "source_kind": "internal_project_rule",
      "source_reference": "#milestones",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "internal_rule_reproducible_I24",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "#milestones"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "M05",
      "statement": "Пример агрегирования",
      "value": 13.333333333333334,
      "unit": "безразмерное отношение",
      "period": "один общий условный период",
      "region": "два независимых условных источника",
      "status": "учебный расчёт",
      "source_url": null,
      "source_locator": "#aggregation",
      "source_version": "v3",
      "access_date": null,
      "transformation": "Выходы 100+100, вложения 10+5; 200/15, округление до 13,33",
      "source_kind": "internal_project_rule",
      "source_reference": "#aggregation",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "internal_rule_reproducible_I24",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "#aggregation"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "D08",
      "statement": "LFP и NMC: RTE",
      "value": 82.59,
      "unit": "%, AC–AC",
      "period": 2021,
      "region": "типовая модель DOE/PNNL, не мировой средний",
      "status": "опубликованное допущение",
      "source_url": "https://www.energy.gov/sites/default/files/2022-09/2022%20Grid%20Energy%20Storage%20Technology%20Cost%20and%20Performance%20Assessment.pdf",
      "source_locator": "Таблица 4.4, стр.22",
      "source_version": "2022",
      "access_date": "2026-09-13",
      "transformation": "Перенос базового значения на границе трансформатора; не DC–DC",
      "source_kind": "external_primary_or_official",
      "source_reference": "https://www.energy.gov/sites/default/files/2022-09/2022%20Grid%20Energy%20Storage%20Technology%20Cost%20and%20Performance%20Assessment.pdf",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "local_primary_pdf_hash_and_locator_verified",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "Table 4.4, printed p.22: 82.59% AC-AC at transformer boundary",
        "sha256": "8c15c2fdd30f0452d75e15767fb9128ac866c3e9dd15a03669d92fad1048976d",
        "local_evidence_file": "source_cache/DOE_Grid_Energy_Storage_2022.pdf"
      },
      "source_file": "source_cache/DOE_Grid_Energy_Storage_2022.pdf",
      "source_sha256": "8c15c2fdd30f0452d75e15767fb9128ac866c3e9dd15a03669d92fad1048976d"
    },
    {
      "id": "D09",
      "statement": "LFP / NMC: циклы",
      "value": [
        2400,
        1520
      ],
      "unit": "циклов",
      "period": 2021,
      "region": "типовая модель DOE/PNNL",
      "status": "опубликованная оценка",
      "source_url": "https://www.energy.gov/sites/default/files/2022-09/2022%20Grid%20Energy%20Storage%20Technology%20Cost%20and%20Performance%20Assessment.pdf",
      "source_locator": "Таблица 4.3, стр.22",
      "source_version": "2022",
      "access_date": "2026-09-13",
      "transformation": "DOD80%; до остаточной энергии, равной 80% номинальной; не универсальная гарантия",
      "source_kind": "external_primary_or_official",
      "source_reference": "https://www.energy.gov/sites/default/files/2022-09/2022%20Grid%20Energy%20Storage%20Technology%20Cost%20and%20Performance%20Assessment.pdf",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "local_primary_pdf_hash_and_locator_verified",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "Table 4.3, printed pp.21-22: LFP 2400; NMC 1520 cycles at 80% DOD",
        "sha256": "8c15c2fdd30f0452d75e15767fb9128ac866c3e9dd15a03669d92fad1048976d",
        "local_evidence_file": "source_cache/DOE_Grid_Energy_Storage_2022.pdf"
      },
      "source_file": "source_cache/DOE_Grid_Energy_Storage_2022.pdf",
      "source_sha256": "8c15c2fdd30f0452d75e15767fb9128ac866c3e9dd15a03669d92fad1048976d"
    },
    {
      "id": "D10",
      "statement": "ГАЭС: RTE и календарный ресурс",
      "value": [
        80,
        60
      ],
      "unit": [
        "%",
        "лет"
      ],
      "period": 2021,
      "region": "типовая модель DOE/PNNL",
      "status": "опубликованное допущение",
      "source_url": "https://www.energy.gov/sites/default/files/2022-09/2022%20Grid%20Energy%20Storage%20Technology%20Cost%20and%20Performance%20Assessment.pdf",
      "source_locator": "Раздел 4.6.4, стр.67",
      "source_version": "2022",
      "access_date": "2026-09-13",
      "transformation": "80% системный RTE; 60 лет расчётного срока",
      "source_kind": "external_primary_or_official",
      "source_reference": "https://www.energy.gov/sites/default/files/2022-09/2022%20Grid%20Energy%20Storage%20Technology%20Cost%20and%20Performance%20Assessment.pdf",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "local_primary_pdf_hash_and_locator_verified",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "Section 4.6.4, printed p.67: PSH 60 years, 80% RTE",
        "sha256": "8c15c2fdd30f0452d75e15767fb9128ac866c3e9dd15a03669d92fad1048976d",
        "local_evidence_file": "source_cache/DOE_Grid_Energy_Storage_2022.pdf"
      },
      "source_file": "source_cache/DOE_Grid_Energy_Storage_2022.pdf",
      "source_sha256": "8c15c2fdd30f0452d75e15767fb9128ac866c3e9dd15a03669d92fad1048976d"
    },
    {
      "id": "D11",
      "statement": "Водород: RTE и календарный ресурс",
      "value": [
        31,
        30
      ],
      "unit": [
        "%",
        "лет"
      ],
      "period": 2021,
      "region": "типовая модель DOE/PNNL",
      "status": "опубликованное допущение",
      "source_url": "https://www.energy.gov/sites/default/files/2022-09/2022%20Grid%20Energy%20Storage%20Technology%20Cost%20and%20Performance%20Assessment.pdf",
      "source_locator": "Раздел 4.9.4; таблица 4.53, стр.111–112",
      "source_version": "2022",
      "access_date": "2026-09-13",
      "transformation": "AC–AC; потери хранения исключены; срок установки предусматривает замены",
      "source_kind": "external_primary_or_official",
      "source_reference": "https://www.energy.gov/sites/default/files/2022-09/2022%20Grid%20Energy%20Storage%20Technology%20Cost%20and%20Performance%20Assessment.pdf",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "local_primary_pdf_hash_and_locator_verified",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "Section 4.9.4 and Table 4.53, printed pp.111-112: HESS 30 years, AC-AC, storage losses excluded",
        "sha256": "8c15c2fdd30f0452d75e15767fb9128ac866c3e9dd15a03669d92fad1048976d",
        "local_evidence_file": "source_cache/DOE_Grid_Energy_Storage_2022.pdf"
      },
      "source_file": "source_cache/DOE_Grid_Energy_Storage_2022.pdf",
      "source_sha256": "8c15c2fdd30f0452d75e15767fb9128ac866c3e9dd15a03669d92fad1048976d"
    },
    {
      "id": "M06",
      "statement": "Учебный баланс переработки",
      "value": [
        100,
        80,
        90,
        72,
        28
      ],
      "unit": [
        "т",
        "%",
        "%",
        "т",
        "т"
      ],
      "period": "один год",
      "region": "условная территория",
      "status": "сохранённый учебный пример I3; заменён проверяемым контрактом M10",
      "source_url": null,
      "source_locator": "#recycling-balance",
      "source_version": "I3",
      "access_date": null,
      "transformation": "100×0,8×0,9=72; 100−72=28; энергозатраты неизвестны; не используется как опубликованная оценка",
      "source_kind": "internal_project_rule",
      "source_reference": "#recycling-balance",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "internal_rule_reproducible_I24",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "#recycling-balance"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "D12",
      "statement": "Декомпозиция конечного спроса по физической активности и энергоёмкости",
      "value": "энергия / физическая единица активности",
      "unit": "зависит от услуги; пример МЭА — МДж/пасс.-км",
      "period": "методика и данные с 2000 года",
      "region": "страны и сектора с доступными данными",
      "status": "официальная методика",
      "source_url": "https://www.iea.org/data-and-statistics/data-tools/energy-efficiency-indicators-data-explorer",
      "source_locator": "Overview; Analysis; activity, structure and efficiency decomposition",
      "source_version": "страница обновлена 2026-07-17",
      "access_date": "2026-09-14",
      "transformation": "В модели сайта используется только общий принцип физическая активность × энергоёмкость; значения МЭА автоматически не подставляются",
      "source_kind": "external_primary_or_official",
      "source_reference": "https://www.iea.org/data-and-statistics/data-tools/energy-efficiency-indicators-data-explorer",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "official_web_method_reopened",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "IEA indicator explorer: activity, structure and efficiency decomposition"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "D13",
      "statement": "Нижневосходящий расчёт энергии для набора физических услуг",
      "value": "сумма произведений объёма услуги и энергетической интенсивности",
      "unit": "МДж или кВт·ч после согласования единиц",
      "period": "сценарная методика 2020",
      "region": "глобальный сценарий достойного уровня жизни",
      "status": "рецензируемая методика",
      "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2020.102168",
      "source_locator": "Methods and data, section 3.1",
      "source_version": "2020",
      "access_date": "2026-09-14",
      "transformation": "Заимствован принцип activity level × energy intensity; опубликованные уровни услуг не перенесены в учебный калькулятор",
      "source_kind": "external_primary_or_official",
      "source_reference": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2020.102168",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "local_primary_pdf_hash_and_locator_verified",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "Section 3.1: bottom-up sum of activity levels multiplied by energy intensities",
        "sha256": "cd25cefae08d8f8adba6133d8b52000b33e821802f3dae6b507e62ddd97a719a",
        "local_evidence_file": "source_cache/Millward_Hopkins_2020_Decent_Living.pdf"
      },
      "source_file": "source_cache/Millward_Hopkins_2020_Decent_Living.pdf",
      "source_sha256": "cd25cefae08d8f8adba6133d8b52000b33e821802f3dae6b507e62ddd97a719a"
    },
    {
      "id": "M07",
      "statement": "Годовой энергетический тест частичной демонстрационной корзины услуг",
      "value": "E_min,s=P×a_s×q_s×i_s; Q_cap,s=A_s/i_s; K_s=A_s/E_min,s; ΔE_s=max(0,E_min,s−A_s)",
      "unit": "ГВт·ч/год, физическая единица услуги/год и % покрытия для обязательной строки",
      "period": "один заданный расчётный год",
      "region": "одна заданная пользователем территория",
      "status": "условный годовой расчётный инструмент; не модель непрерывной доступности и не прогноз",
      "source_url": null,
      "source_locator": "#service-demand; app.js serviceDemandState; service-demand-model.json",
      "source_version": "I18",
      "access_date": null,
      "transformation": "Для каждой строки сначала задаётся статус required/unknown/N/A. Только валидные обязательные строки с положительным нормативом рассчитываются; N/A исключаются; нулевой норматив не даёт PASS. Публикуются вектор K_s, число дефицитов, абсолютные ΔE_s и физический недовыпуск. A_s — выделенная одной услуге годовая конечная энергия без двойного счёта; это не твёрдая мощность и не доказательство непрерывной доставки.",
      "source_kind": "internal_project_rule",
      "source_reference": "#service-demand; app.js serviceDemandState; service-demand-model.json",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "internal_rule_reproducible_I24",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "#service-demand; app.js serviceDemandState; service-demand-model.json"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "D14",
      "statement": "WPP 2024: population and median age by UN major region",
      "value": [
        {
          "region": "World",
          "location_code": 900,
          "population_million_2023_estimate": 8091.735,
          "median_age_2023_estimate": 30.364,
          "population_million_2050_medium": 9664.379,
          "median_age_2050_medium": 36.068,
          "population_change_percent": 19.435,
          "source_rows": [
            91,
            44
          ]
        },
        {
          "region": "Africa",
          "location_code": 903,
          "population_million_2023_estimate": 1480.771,
          "median_age_2023_estimate": 19.032,
          "population_million_2050_medium": 2466.648,
          "median_age_2050_medium": 24.382,
          "population_change_percent": 66.579,
          "source_rows": [
            2537,
            2589
          ]
        },
        {
          "region": "Asia",
          "location_code": 935,
          "population_million_2023_estimate": 4778.004,
          "median_age_2023_estimate": 31.737,
          "population_million_2050_medium": 5280.378,
          "median_age_2050_medium": 39.822,
          "population_change_percent": 10.514,
          "source_rows": [
            7273,
            7517
          ]
        },
        {
          "region": "Europe",
          "location_code": 908,
          "population_million_2023_estimate": 745.603,
          "median_age_2023_estimate": 42.231,
          "population_million_2050_medium": 703.028,
          "median_age_2050_medium": 46.217,
          "population_change_percent": -5.71,
          "source_rows": [
            11491,
            11906
          ]
        },
        {
          "region": "Latin America and the Caribbean",
          "location_code": 904,
          "population_million_2023_estimate": 658.892,
          "median_age_2023_estimate": 30.928,
          "population_million_2050_medium": 730.057,
          "median_age_2050_medium": 40.465,
          "population_change_percent": 10.801,
          "source_rows": [
            15562,
            16142
          ]
        },
        {
          "region": "Northern America",
          "location_code": 905,
          "population_million_2023_estimate": 382.903,
          "median_age_2023_estimate": 38.265,
          "population_million_2050_medium": 426.58,
          "median_age_2050_medium": 42.182,
          "population_change_percent": 11.407,
          "source_rows": [
            19558,
            20300
          ]
        },
        {
          "region": "Oceania",
          "location_code": 909,
          "population_million_2023_estimate": 45.563,
          "median_age_2023_estimate": 32.885,
          "population_million_2050_medium": 57.688,
          "median_age_2050_medium": 37.213,
          "population_change_percent": 26.612,
          "source_rows": [
            20002,
            20762
          ]
        }
      ],
      "unit": {
        "population": "million persons",
        "median_age": "years",
        "change": "%"
      },
      "period": {
        "estimate": 2023,
        "medium_variant": 2050,
        "reference_date": "1 July"
      },
      "region": "World and six UN major regions",
      "status": "2023 estimate and 2050 medium-variant projection",
      "source_url": "https://population.un.org/wpp/assets/Excel%20Files/1_Indicator%20(Standard)/EXCEL_FILES/1_General/WPP2024_GEN_F01_DEMOGRAPHIC_INDICATORS_COMPACT.xlsx",
      "source_locator": "Estimates and Medium variant sheets; source row retained for every region",
      "source_version": "World Population Prospects 2024, File GEN/01/REV1",
      "access_date": "2026-09-14",
      "transformation": "Population source unit thousands divided by 1000; site display rounds population to 0.001 million, median age and change to 0.1",
      "source_sha256": "98e34d9b65b53858cd08a57a566e45050b08093ad85ba5714fe6fbd78055ae6d",
      "source_kind": "external_primary_or_official",
      "source_reference": "https://population.un.org/wpp/assets/Excel%20Files/1_Indicator%20(Standard)/EXCEL_FILES/1_General/WPP2024_GEN_F01_DEMOGRAPHIC_INDICATORS_COMPACT.xlsx",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "local_primary_xlsx_cells_verified",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "All 14 regional 2023/2050 cells and all 26 World 2025-2050 cells matched recorded source rows",
        "sha256": "98e34d9b65b53858cd08a57a566e45050b08093ad85ba5714fe6fbd78055ae6d",
        "local_evidence_file": "source_cache/WPP2024_GEN_F01_DEMOGRAPHIC_INDICATORS_COMPACT.xlsx"
      },
      "source_file": "source_cache/WPP2024_GEN_F01_DEMOGRAPHIC_INDICATORS_COMPACT.xlsx"
    },
    {
      "id": "D15",
      "statement": "WPP 2024 methodology and projection status",
      "value": "2050 medium variant is a projection, distinct from the 2023 estimate",
      "unit": "неприменимо — методическое утверждение без числовой ячейки",
      "period": "WPP 2024 release",
      "region": "UN WPP locations",
      "status": "official methodology",
      "source_url": "https://population.un.org/wpp/assets/Files/WPP2024_Methodology.pdf",
      "source_locator": "Methodology of the United Nations population estimates and projections",
      "source_version": "WPP 2024",
      "access_date": "2026-09-14",
      "transformation": "Interpretive boundary only; no numeric transformation",
      "source_kind": "external_primary_or_official",
      "source_reference": "https://population.un.org/wpp/assets/Files/WPP2024_Methodology.pdf",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "local_primary_pdf_hash_and_locator_verified",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "Official WPP 2024 methodology; estimates and medium-variant method",
        "sha256": "0c98d8131e61227596fabf21328024a3c6ba05c27dcbbdbf507e5f7edd8a35c9",
        "local_evidence_file": "source_cache/WPP2024_Methodology.pdf"
      },
      "source_file": "source_cache/WPP2024_Methodology.pdf",
      "source_sha256": "0c98d8131e61227596fabf21328024a3c6ba05c27dcbbdbf507e5f7edd8a35c9"
    },
    {
      "id": "D16",
      "statement": "Access to electricity (% of population)",
      "value": [
        {
          "region_code": "WLD",
          "region": "Мир",
          "percent_raw": 91.9264843853681,
          "percent_display": 91.9
        },
        {
          "region_code": "EAS",
          "region": "Восточная Азия и Тихоокеанский регион",
          "percent_raw": 98.5597948238034,
          "percent_display": 98.6
        },
        {
          "region_code": "ECS",
          "region": "Европа и Центральная Азия",
          "percent_raw": 99.998857471373,
          "percent_display": 100
        },
        {
          "region_code": "LCN",
          "region": "Латинская Америка и Карибский бассейн",
          "percent_raw": 98.0459111591331,
          "percent_display": 98
        },
        {
          "region_code": "MEA",
          "region": "Ближний Восток, Северная Африка, Афганистан и Пакистан",
          "percent_raw": 96.7736884722286,
          "percent_display": 96.8
        },
        {
          "region_code": "NAC",
          "region": "Северная Америка",
          "percent_raw": 100,
          "percent_display": 100
        },
        {
          "region_code": "SAS",
          "region": "Южная Азия",
          "percent_raw": 99.8246424902051,
          "percent_display": 99.8
        },
        {
          "region_code": "SSF",
          "region": "Африка к югу от Сахары",
          "percent_raw": 55.1103542559,
          "percent_display": 55.1
        }
      ],
      "unit": "% of population",
      "period": 2024,
      "region": "World and seven World Bank regional aggregates",
      "status": "published WDI aggregate",
      "source_url": "https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/EG.ELC.ACCS.ZS",
      "source_locator": "https://api.worldbank.org/v2/country/WLD;EAS;ECS;LCN;MEA;NAC;SAS;SSF/indicator/EG.ELC.ACCS.ZS?date=2022:2024&format=json&per_page=200",
      "source_version": "API source 2; last updated 2026-07-13",
      "access_date": "2026-09-14",
      "transformation": "Raw API value retained; site display rounded to 0.1 percentage point",
      "data_sha256": "50ebd4117b508563d793289b1911cc488af4258751fe9c68b693e502f97b770d",
      "source_kind": "external_primary_or_official",
      "source_reference": "https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/EG.ELC.ACCS.ZS",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "local_official_api_snapshot_values_verified",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "All eight 2024 regional aggregates matched cached official API snapshot",
        "sha256": "50ebd4117b508563d793289b1911cc488af4258751fe9c68b693e502f97b770d",
        "local_evidence_file": "source_cache/WB_EG.ELC.ACCS.ZS_2022_2024.json"
      },
      "source_file": "source_cache/WB_EG.ELC.ACCS.ZS_2022_2024.json",
      "source_sha256": "50ebd4117b508563d793289b1911cc488af4258751fe9c68b693e502f97b770d"
    },
    {
      "id": "D17",
      "statement": "People using safely managed drinking water services (% of population)",
      "value": [
        {
          "region_code": "WLD",
          "region": "Мир",
          "percent_raw": 73.6686144265244,
          "percent_display": 73.7
        },
        {
          "region_code": "EAS",
          "region": "Восточная Азия и Тихоокеанский регион",
          "percent_raw": 75.2336082310621,
          "percent_display": 75.2
        },
        {
          "region_code": "ECS",
          "region": "Европа и Центральная Азия",
          "percent_raw": 92.468529296819,
          "percent_display": 92.5
        },
        {
          "region_code": "LCN",
          "region": "Латинская Америка и Карибский бассейн",
          "percent_raw": 78.9601794459191,
          "percent_display": 79
        },
        {
          "region_code": "MEA",
          "region": "Ближний Восток, Северная Африка, Афганистан и Пакистан",
          "percent_raw": 65.6173396110979,
          "percent_display": 65.6
        },
        {
          "region_code": "NAC",
          "region": "Северная Америка",
          "percent_raw": 97.3964172267457,
          "percent_display": 97.4
        },
        {
          "region_code": "SAS",
          "region": "Южная Азия",
          "percent_raw": 77.5514601972461,
          "percent_display": 77.6
        },
        {
          "region_code": "SSF",
          "region": "Африка к югу от Сахары",
          "percent_raw": 32.4155533520093,
          "percent_display": 32.4
        }
      ],
      "unit": "% of population",
      "period": 2024,
      "region": "World and seven World Bank regional aggregates",
      "status": "published WDI aggregate; primary organization WHO/UNICEF JMP",
      "source_url": "https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SH.H2O.SMDW.ZS",
      "source_locator": "https://api.worldbank.org/v2/country/WLD;EAS;ECS;LCN;MEA;NAC;SAS;SSF/indicator/SH.H2O.SMDW.ZS?date=2022:2024&format=json&per_page=200",
      "source_version": "API source 2; last updated 2026-07-13",
      "access_date": "2026-09-14",
      "transformation": "Raw API value retained; site display rounded to 0.1 percentage point",
      "data_sha256": "c6c4a2f0b831de9b4d3820426b8b4fe021af9865d074d2a82ad7014a6d4f1c1c",
      "source_kind": "external_primary_or_official",
      "source_reference": "https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SH.H2O.SMDW.ZS",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "local_official_api_snapshot_values_verified",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "All eight 2024 regional aggregates matched cached official API snapshot",
        "sha256": "c6c4a2f0b831de9b4d3820426b8b4fe021af9865d074d2a82ad7014a6d4f1c1c",
        "local_evidence_file": "source_cache/WB_SH.H2O.SMDW.ZS_2022_2024.json"
      },
      "source_file": "source_cache/WB_SH.H2O.SMDW.ZS_2022_2024.json",
      "source_sha256": "c6c4a2f0b831de9b4d3820426b8b4fe021af9865d074d2a82ad7014a6d4f1c1c"
    },
    {
      "id": "D18",
      "statement": "People using safely managed sanitation services (% of population)",
      "value": [
        {
          "region_code": "WLD",
          "region": "Мир",
          "percent_raw": 58.4951883486035,
          "percent_display": 58.5
        },
        {
          "region_code": "EAS",
          "region": "Восточная Азия и Тихоокеанский регион",
          "percent_raw": 63.6400138579317,
          "percent_display": 63.6
        },
        {
          "region_code": "ECS",
          "region": "Европа и Центральная Азия",
          "percent_raw": 80.202083220941,
          "percent_display": 80.2
        },
        {
          "region_code": "LCN",
          "region": "Латинская Америка и Карибский бассейн",
          "percent_raw": 51.2209972924919,
          "percent_display": 51.2
        },
        {
          "region_code": "MEA",
          "region": "Ближний Восток, Северная Африка, Афганистан и Пакистан",
          "percent_raw": 54.4427793216174,
          "percent_display": 54.4
        },
        {
          "region_code": "NAC",
          "region": "Северная Америка",
          "percent_raw": 95.3904661396555,
          "percent_display": 95.4
        },
        {
          "region_code": "SAS",
          "region": "Южная Азия",
          "percent_raw": 60.0591907163454,
          "percent_display": 60.1
        },
        {
          "region_code": "SSF",
          "region": "Африка к югу от Сахары",
          "percent_raw": 25.9074828232473,
          "percent_display": 25.9
        }
      ],
      "unit": "% of population",
      "period": 2024,
      "region": "World and seven World Bank regional aggregates",
      "status": "published WDI aggregate; primary organization WHO/UNICEF JMP",
      "source_url": "https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SH.STA.SMSS.ZS",
      "source_locator": "https://api.worldbank.org/v2/country/WLD;EAS;ECS;LCN;MEA;NAC;SAS;SSF/indicator/SH.STA.SMSS.ZS?date=2022:2024&format=json&per_page=200",
      "source_version": "API source 2; last updated 2026-07-13",
      "access_date": "2026-09-14",
      "transformation": "Raw API value retained; site display rounded to 0.1 percentage point",
      "data_sha256": "254c8f68f184896da4063554a103321fd5f9a139c52acd89e88a315910e94228",
      "source_kind": "external_primary_or_official",
      "source_reference": "https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SH.STA.SMSS.ZS",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "local_official_api_snapshot_values_verified",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "All eight 2024 regional aggregates matched cached official API snapshot",
        "sha256": "254c8f68f184896da4063554a103321fd5f9a139c52acd89e88a315910e94228",
        "local_evidence_file": "source_cache/WB_SH.STA.SMSS.ZS_2022_2024.json"
      },
      "source_file": "source_cache/WB_SH.STA.SMSS.ZS_2022_2024.json",
      "source_sha256": "254c8f68f184896da4063554a103321fd5f9a139c52acd89e88a315910e94228"
    },
    {
      "id": "M08",
      "statement": "I9 population and access extraction contract",
      "value": "UN and World Bank region memberships are preserved separately; no row-wise join",
      "unit": "неприменимо — методическое утверждение без числовой ячейки",
      "period": "I9 build",
      "region": "source-defined aggregates",
      "status": "reproducible transformation rule",
      "source_url": null,
      "source_locator": "build_i9_population_access_data.py; population-access-data.json; #population-access",
      "source_version": "I9",
      "access_date": null,
      "transformation": "Validate expected codes, years and 0–100 bounds; retain raw values, source hashes and WPP row locators; round only for display",
      "source_kind": "internal_project_rule",
      "source_reference": "build_i9_population_access_data.py; population-access-data.json; #population-access",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "internal_rule_reproducible_I24",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "build_i9_population_access_data.py; population-access-data.json; #population-access"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "M09",
      "statement": "I16 annual EROI extraction contract",
      "value": "Three source rows expanded into 50 annual cells each; stages remain separate",
      "unit": "неприменимо — методическое утверждение без числовой ячейки",
      "period": "1971–2020",
      "region": "WRLD",
      "status": "reproducible transformation rule",
      "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.25311358",
      "source_locator": "file 46240243; build_i16_three_boundaries.py; eroi-history-data.json; #eroi-history",
      "source_version": "Figshare version 1; I16",
      "access_date": "2026-09-14",
      "transformation": "Verify source SHA256; exact row-key match; require continuous year columns and non-empty values; preserve raw decimal strings; round only for HTML display",
      "data_sha256": "12241f109b0e1f540f591fbaec912961ea0b458365a029f7dae5396cfd10340d",
      "source_kind": "internal_project_rule",
      "source_reference": "https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.25311358",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "internal_rule_reproducible_I24",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "file 46240243; build_i16_three_boundaries.py; eroi-history-data.json; #eroi-history"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "D19",
      "statement": "Доступный лом и вторичная поставка меди в сценарии APS",
      "value": {
        "available_eol_scrap_mt": {
          "2030": 19,
          "2050": 27
        },
        "share_of_demand_percent": {
          "2030": 60,
          "2050": 70
        },
        "total_secondary_supply_mt": {
          "2030": 15,
          "2050": 31
        }
      },
      "unit": "млн т Cu и % спроса",
      "period": [
        2030,
        2050
      ],
      "region": "мир",
      "status": "опубликованная сценарная оценка APS",
      "source_locator": "PDF pp. 83-84, Figures 2.23-2.24",
      "transformation": "Опубликованные округлённые значения; доступный лом отделён от поставки после потерь",
      "source_url": "https://www.iea.org/reports/recycling-of-critical-minerals",
      "source_version": "2024 report, revised December 2025",
      "access_date": "2026-09-14",
      "source_file": "source_cache/IEA_Recycling_of_Critical_Minerals_rev_2025.pdf",
      "source_sha256": "bf54828d9f8b9e05646b0f22e5b1a4a9b183b590974974abe1824d4f053c3263",
      "source_kind": "external_primary_or_official",
      "source_reference": "https://www.iea.org/reports/recycling-of-critical-minerals",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "local_primary_pdf_hash_and_locator_rechecked",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "PDF pp.83-84, Figures 2.23-2.24",
        "sha256": "bf54828d9f8b9e05646b0f22e5b1a4a9b183b590974974abe1824d4f053c3263",
        "local_evidence_file": "source_cache/IEA_Recycling_of_Critical_Minerals_rev_2025.pdf"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "D20",
      "statement": "Сроки службы медьсодержащих изделий и границы доступного лома",
      "value": {
        "consumer_electrical_years": [
          5,
          10
        ],
        "industrial_electrical_and_buildings_years": [
          20,
          50
        ]
      },
      "unit": "лет",
      "period": "классы изделий",
      "region": "мир",
      "status": "опубликованные описательные диапазоны",
      "source_locator": "PDF pp. 32-33, 83, 85",
      "transformation": "Диапазоны перенесены без усреднения; не назначены каждому изделию",
      "source_url": "https://www.iea.org/reports/recycling-of-critical-minerals",
      "source_version": "2024 report, revised December 2025",
      "access_date": "2026-09-14",
      "source_file": "source_cache/IEA_Recycling_of_Critical_Minerals_rev_2025.pdf",
      "source_sha256": "bf54828d9f8b9e05646b0f22e5b1a4a9b183b590974974abe1824d4f053c3263",
      "source_kind": "external_primary_or_official",
      "source_reference": "https://www.iea.org/reports/recycling-of-critical-minerals",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "local_primary_pdf_hash_and_locator_rechecked",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "PDF pp.32-33, 83, 85",
        "sha256": "bf54828d9f8b9e05646b0f22e5b1a4a9b183b590974974abe1824d4f053c3263",
        "local_evidence_file": "source_cache/IEA_Recycling_of_Critical_Minerals_rev_2025.pdf"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "D21",
      "statement": "Относительные энергозатраты переработанного алюминия",
      "value": 95,
      "unit": "% меньше энергии, чем первичное производство алюминия",
      "period": "сравнение технологических маршрутов",
      "region": "не задано в источнике как географический ряд",
      "status": "опубликованная сравнительная оценка",
      "source_locator": "PDF p. 40, Box 1.3",
      "transformation": "Относительная оценка; не преобразована в кВт·ч/т и не перенесена на медь",
      "source_url": "https://www.iea.org/reports/recycling-of-critical-minerals",
      "source_version": "2024 report, revised December 2025",
      "access_date": "2026-09-14",
      "source_file": "source_cache/IEA_Recycling_of_Critical_Minerals_rev_2025.pdf",
      "source_sha256": "bf54828d9f8b9e05646b0f22e5b1a4a9b183b590974974abe1824d4f053c3263",
      "source_kind": "external_primary_or_official",
      "source_reference": "https://www.iea.org/reports/recycling-of-critical-minerals",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "local_primary_pdf_hash_and_locator_rechecked",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "PDF p.40, Box 1.3",
        "sha256": "bf54828d9f8b9e05646b0f22e5b1a4a9b183b590974974abe1824d4f053c3263",
        "local_evidence_file": "source_cache/IEA_Recycling_of_Critical_Minerals_rev_2025.pdf"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "M10",
      "statement": "Условный массовый баланс переработки I11",
      "value": null,
      "unit": "масса и проценты в одной пользовательской границе",
      "period": "один выбранный период",
      "region": "одна выбранная пользователем система",
      "status": "расчётный инструмент без встроенного прогноза",
      "source_url": null,
      "source_locator": "#recycling-limits; recycling-boundaries-data.json",
      "source_version": "NP176-I11",
      "access_date": null,
      "transformation": "Выход=лом×сбор×сортировка×процесс; первичная потребность=max(спрос−выход,0); пустой вход=UNKNOWN",
      "source_kind": "internal_project_rule",
      "source_reference": "#recycling-limits; recycling-boundaries-data.json",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "internal_rule_reproducible_I24",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "#recycling-limits; recycling-boundaries-data.json"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "D22",
      "statement": "Три сценарных траектории systemwide EROI мировой электроэнергетики",
      "value": {
        "early": [
          [
            2025,
            23.7
          ],
          [
            2030,
            22
          ],
          [
            2035,
            17.3
          ],
          [
            2040,
            16.8
          ],
          [
            2045,
            16.7
          ],
          [
            2050,
            16.7
          ]
        ],
        "target": [
          [
            2025,
            24.5
          ],
          [
            2030,
            22.9
          ],
          [
            2035,
            21.7
          ],
          [
            2040,
            19.8
          ],
          [
            2045,
            18.9
          ],
          [
            2050,
            18.7
          ]
        ],
        "later": [
          [
            2025,
            18.2
          ],
          [
            2030,
            18.7
          ],
          [
            2035,
            19.5
          ],
          [
            2040,
            20.4
          ],
          [
            2045,
            21.2
          ],
          [
            2050,
            21.3
          ]
        ]
      },
      "unit": "безразмерный EROI",
      "period": [
        2025,
        2050
      ],
      "region": "мир; агрегат девяти регионов",
      "status": "приближённая оцифровка опубликованного модельного рисунка",
      "source_url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-023-44232-9",
      "source_locator": "Figure 2a-b; final consumption (F)",
      "source_version": "Nature Communications 15, 208 (2024)",
      "access_date": "2026-09-14",
      "source_file": "source_cache/Sahin_2024_Figure2.png",
      "source_sha256": "4e461931414fd7a79ffd81991bbe528db3b90838fdaa0dcc5073acfe4afcc44c",
      "transformation": "Приближённое считывание осей до 0,1; не авторская таблица; три из девяти маршрутов без ранжирования",
      "source_kind": "external_primary_or_official",
      "source_reference": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-023-44232-9",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "local_primary_article_figure_hash_rechecked",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "Figure 2a-b; digitised nodes remain approximate to 0.1",
        "sha256": "4e461931414fd7a79ffd81991bbe528db3b90838fdaa0dcc5073acfe4afcc44c",
        "local_evidence_file": "source_cache/Sahin_2024_Figure2.png"
      },
      "numerator_stage": "net electricity delivered to end users at final consumption point F after transmission and distribution losses",
      "denominator_stage": "systemwide energy investment converted to electricity quality under LUT-EROI",
      "cost_composition": "resources; construction/decommissioning materials and consumables; transport; operational consumables; storage; recycling and embodied grid expansion energy excluded"
    },
    {
      "id": "M11",
      "statement": "Разделение общей шкалы EROI и сценарного EROI электроэнергетики",
      "value": null,
      "unit": "год и EROI",
      "period": [
        2026,
        2050
      ],
      "region": "мир в границе источника",
      "status": "интерфейсное преобразование",
      "source_url": null,
      "source_locator": "#milestones; eroi-scenario-pathways.json",
      "source_version": "NP176-I14",
      "access_date": null,
      "transformation": "Год интерполирует только показатель электроэнергетики; общая шкала остаётся ручной и независимой; переноса на всю энергетику нет.",
      "source_kind": "internal_project_rule",
      "source_reference": "#milestones; eroi-scenario-pathways.json",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "internal_rule_reproducible_I24",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "#milestones; eroi-scenario-pathways.json"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "D23",
      "statement": "Electricity share of world total final energy consumption",
      "value": 21,
      "unit": "%",
      "period": 2025,
      "region": "world",
      "status": "IEA 2026 estimate",
      "source_url": "https://www.iea.org/reports/electricity-2026/demand",
      "source_locator": "Demand; electrification share increases from 21% in 2025 to 24% in 2030",
      "source_version": "Electricity 2026",
      "access_date": "2026-09-19",
      "transformation": "Value retained as published; not interpreted as a primary-energy share or whole-energy EROI weight",
      "source_kind": "external_primary_or_official",
      "source_reference": "https://www.iea.org/reports/electricity-2026/demand",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "official_web_text_reopened",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "IEA Electricity 2026: electricity share rises from 21% in 2025 to 24% in 2030"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "D24",
      "statement": "Переработка меди использует около 15% энергии, необходимой для добычи и переработки первичной меди",
      "value": 15,
      "unit": "% энергии первичного маршрута",
      "period": "опубликовано в отчёте 2024, revision 2025-12; не временной ряд",
      "region": "отраслевой средний ориентир; география отдельно не задана",
      "status": "опубликованная относительная оценка",
      "source_locator": "PDF page 138; Cross-cutting issues; Comparison of recycled versus primary production",
      "transformation": "Перенесено как относительная доля без преобразования в кВт·ч/т; не переносится на конкретный маршрут",
      "source_url": "https://www.iea.org/reports/recycling-of-critical-minerals",
      "source_version": "IEA 2024; revised December 2025",
      "access_date": "2026-09-14",
      "source_file": "source_cache/IEA_Recycling_of_Critical_Minerals_rev_2025.pdf",
      "source_sha256": "bf54828d9f8b9e05646b0f22e5b1a4a9b183b590974974abe1824d4f053c3263",
      "source_kind": "external_primary_or_official",
      "source_reference": "https://www.iea.org/reports/recycling-of-critical-minerals",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "local_primary_pdf_hash_and_locator_rechecked",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "PDF p.138: recycled copper about 15% of primary-route energy",
        "sha256": "bf54828d9f8b9e05646b0f22e5b1a4a9b183b590974974abe1824d4f053c3263",
        "local_evidence_file": "source_cache/IEA_Recycling_of_Critical_Minerals_rev_2025.pdf"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "D25",
      "statement": "Годовая первичная стадия EROI мирового ископаемого энергомикса",
      "value": [
        44.6492335447149,
        45.146245460237736,
        45.381962177172866,
        45.28468860419131,
        43.66697545483977,
        43.73647456867836,
        43.150891869754844,
        42.07414311320249,
        43.835825526874835,
        44.94734409877042,
        43.429955962912175,
        40.009699132744636,
        39.20771321017132,
        38.51604188105518,
        36.893604142016095,
        37.45292609054598,
        36.49689203683771,
        36.36930616659439,
        36.50496351730387,
        34.65968273925051,
        34.851790008964834,
        33.8286353972825,
        31.96990177696743,
        31.51233549608252,
        32.71498113189834,
        32.26837778549123,
        31.32767304925545,
        30.810941088742865,
        31.175941081645487,
        31.325125552477424,
        29.748144838416724,
        28.958550213669646,
        28.205880455549668,
        29.210894476200835,
        27.609486620870193,
        27.57306473127678,
        26.644098675246067,
        26.163928466300995,
        26.23647577171396,
        25.50116442967191,
        24.939739467057773,
        24.88599772587792,
        24.102420854934586,
        27.17737741768555,
        27.91930068024443,
        27.017322626013694,
        27.583931735243024,
        27.138708749454963,
        27.196598019860946,
        27.543945141938924
      ],
      "unit": "безразмерное отношение",
      "period": [
        1971,
        2020
      ],
      "region": "мир (WRLD)",
      "status": "опубликованная модельная оценка",
      "source_url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41560-024-01518-6",
      "source_locator": "Fig. 2; released dataset file 46240243; row Primary / All fossil fuels / Included",
      "source_version": "Nature Energy 2024; Figshare version 1",
      "access_date": "2026-09-14",
      "transformation": "Широкая CSV-строка развёрнута в 50 годовых ячеек; округление до 0,001 только в HTML; без интерполяции и экстраполяции",
      "data_file": "eroi-history-data.json",
      "source_file": "source_cache/figshare_46240243_global_erois.csv",
      "source_sha256": "12241f109b0e1f540f591fbaec912961ea0b458365a029f7dae5396cfd10340d",
      "numerator": "первичная энергия, произведённая отраслями ископаемого топлива",
      "denominator": "первичная энергия прямых и косвенных вложений в отрасли ископаемого топлива",
      "indirect_energy": "Included",
      "capital_energy": "Excluded",
      "source_kind": "external_primary_or_official",
      "source_reference": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41560-024-01518-6",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "local_hash_and_row_locator_rechecked",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "Figshare released CSV row: Primary / All fossil fuels / Included",
        "sha256": "12241f109b0e1f540f591fbaec912961ea0b458365a029f7dae5396cfd10340d",
        "local_evidence_file": "source_cache/figshare_46240243_global_erois.csv"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "M12",
      "statement": "Двунаправленная навигация год ↔ EROI внутри выбранной сценарной линии",
      "value": null,
      "unit": "год и безразмерное отношение",
      "period": [
        2025,
        2050
      ],
      "region": "мир, электроэнергетика в границе источника",
      "status": "интерфейсное преобразование",
      "source_url": null,
      "source_locator": "timeline.html; timeline.js; eroi-scenario-pathways.json",
      "source_version": "NP176-I21-local",
      "access_date": null,
      "transformation": "Прямое направление использует кусочно-линейную интерполяцию между округлёнными пятилетними узлами. Обратное направление решает все сегменты той же отображаемой функции, объединяет плоские диапазоны, сохраняет отдельные решения и сообщает, что видимое плато может быть следствием округления до 0,1.",
      "source_kind": "internal_project_rule",
      "source_reference": "timeline.html; timeline.js; eroi-scenario-pathways.json",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "internal_rule_reproducible_I24",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "timeline.html; timeline.js; eroi-scenario-pathways.json"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "D26",
      "statement": "Один сопоставимый набор модельных EROI электрогенерации",
      "value": {
        "coal": 13,
        "gas": 3,
        "hydro": 38,
        "nuclear": 25,
        "solar": 4,
        "wind": 19
      },
      "unit": "TJ electricity output / TJ primary-energy-equivalent invested",
      "period": "published 2016; parameter table, not a time series",
      "region": "generic technology inputs used by the published dynamic model",
      "status": "published model inputs; not universal technology estimates",
      "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.3390/su8050421",
      "source_locator": "Table 1, EROI (TJe/TJpte)",
      "source_version": "Sustainability 8(5), 421 (2016)",
      "access_date": "2026-09-19",
      "transformation": "Values transcribed without averaging; labels translated; kept separate from Sahin systemwide pathways and Aramendia fossil time series",
      "source_file": "source_cache/Kessides_Wade_2016_Dynamic_EROI.pdf",
      "source_sha256": "20890ee239bae0755e2cceb3ebbf9789b3dd96cedafb0cfb74f332086842cf57",
      "source_kind": "external_primary_or_official",
      "source_reference": "https://doi.org/10.3390/su8050421",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "local_primary_pdf_hash_and_locator_verified",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "Table 1 values 13, 3, 38, 25, 4, 19; PTE basis; integration/storage/transmission excluded",
        "sha256": "20890ee239bae0755e2cceb3ebbf9789b3dd96cedafb0cfb74f332086842cf57",
        "local_evidence_file": "source_cache/Kessides_Wade_2016_Dynamic_EROI.pdf"
      },
      "numerator_stage": "gross electrical energy produced over facility lifetime",
      "denominator_stage": "primary-thermal-equivalent energy invested over facility lifetime",
      "cost_composition": "fabrication, construction, operation, decommissioning; fuel mining/processing/delivery without fuel energy content; grid integration/storage/transmission embodied energy excluded for solar and wind"
    },
    {
      "id": "D27",
      "statement": "Life-cycle greenhouse-gas ranges for electricity generation options",
      "value": {
        "coal": [
          751,
          1095
        ],
        "gas": [
          403,
          513
        ],
        "solar_pv": [
          8,
          83
        ],
        "wind": [
          7.8,
          23
        ],
        "hydro": [
          6,
          147
        ],
        "nuclear": [
          5.1,
          6.4
        ]
      },
      "unit": "g CO2-eq/kWh electricity, full life cycle",
      "period": "report published 2021; technology cases, not a time series",
      "region": "technology and regional cases assessed by UNECE",
      "status": "published comparative LCA result",
      "source_url": "https://unece.org/sites/default/files/2021-09/202109_UNECE_LCA_1.2_clean.pdf",
      "source_locator": "Section 5.1 Discussion; technology chapters; hydropower caveat",
      "source_version": "UNECE Life Cycle Assessment of Electricity Generation Options, September 2021",
      "access_date": "2026-09-19",
      "transformation": "Ranges transcribed from the report conclusion; onshore and offshore wind combined to 7.8–23 for the summary card; no cross-impact score created",
      "source_file": null,
      "source_sha256": null,
      "source_kind": "external_primary_or_official",
      "source_reference": "https://unece.org/sites/default/files/2021-09/202109_UNECE_LCA_1.2_clean.pdf",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "official_primary_pdf_text_reopened",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "UNECE 2021 LCA, section 5.1 and technology chapters; ranges retain hydro caveat"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "M13",
      "statement": "Dimensionless service-efficiency index with separate rebound decomposition",
      "value": "I_eff=(S/S0)/(E/E0); teaching example I_eff=1.33 and direct rebound=33%",
      "unit": "dimensionless; service and energy retain their physical units",
      "period": "one explicitly selected comparison period",
      "region": "one service and one consistent boundary",
      "status": "project calculation rule",
      "source_url": null,
      "source_locator": "index.html#efficiency-index",
      "source_version": "NP176-I21-local",
      "access_date": null,
      "transformation": "Normalize service and energy to the same baseline; do not aggregate unlike services; separate activity, structural and rebound effects",
      "source_kind": "internal_project_rule",
      "source_reference": "index.html#efficiency-index",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "internal_rule_reproducible_I24",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "index.html#efficiency-index"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "M14",
      "statement": "Physical energy metrics, monetary metrics and causal econometric claims are not interchangeable",
      "value": null,
      "unit": "J/kWh/GW/GWh; dimensionless EROI; currency per energy/capacity/time; econometric coefficient",
      "period": "all displayed periods",
      "region": "all displayed regions",
      "status": "project boundary rule",
      "source_url": null,
      "source_locator": "index.html#physical-money",
      "source_version": "NP176-I21-local",
      "access_date": null,
      "transformation": "No currency-to-EROI conversion; no causal economic coefficient without a separately identified model",
      "source_kind": "internal_project_rule",
      "source_reference": "index.html#physical-money",
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "internal_rule_reproducible_I24",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-20",
        "evidence": "index.html#physical-money"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "D28",
      "statement": "Четыре сценарные траектории EROI всей мировой энергосистемы на границе конечной энергии",
      "value": {
        "led": {
          "median": [
            [
              2020,
              7.0367
            ],
            [
              2021,
              7.2415
            ],
            [
              2022,
              6.9012
            ],
            [
              2023,
              6.6982
            ],
            [
              2024,
              6.5791
            ],
            [
              2025,
              6.5202
            ],
            [
              2026,
              6.5097
            ],
            [
              2027,
              6.546
            ],
            [
              2028,
              6.6324
            ],
            [
              2029,
              6.773
            ],
            [
              2030,
              6.9729
            ],
            [
              2031,
              7.1138
            ],
            [
              2032,
              7.1691
            ],
            [
              2033,
              7.2636
            ],
            [
              2034,
              7.3963
            ],
            [
              2035,
              7.5664
            ],
            [
              2036,
              7.6737
            ],
            [
              2037,
              7.8921
            ],
            [
              2038,
              8.1302
            ],
            [
              2039,
              8.3835
            ],
            [
              2040,
              8.6345
            ],
            [
              2041,
              8.6893
            ],
            [
              2042,
              8.5774
            ],
            [
              2043,
              8.5601
            ],
            [
              2044,
              8.6268
            ],
            [
              2045,
              8.7759
            ],
            [
              2046,
              8.9306
            ],
            [
              2047,
              9.0495
            ],
            [
              2048,
              9.1764
            ],
            [
              2049,
              9.3129
            ],
            [
              2050,
              9.4516
            ],
            [
              2051,
              9.2287
            ],
            [
              2052,
              8.72
            ],
            [
              2053,
              8.3338
            ],
            [
              2054,
              8.0483
            ],
            [
              2055,
              7.8442
            ],
            [
              2056,
              7.6961
            ],
            [
              2057,
              7.5831
            ],
            [
              2058,
              7.5432
            ],
            [
              2059,
              7.5737
            ],
            [
              2060,
              7.3598
            ],
            [
              2061,
              7.6502
            ],
            [
              2062,
              7.5626
            ],
            [
              2063,
              7.4911
            ],
            [
              2064,
              7.4374
            ],
            [
              2065,
              7.3938
            ],
            [
              2066,
              7.2789
            ],
            [
              2067,
              7.1148
            ],
            [
              2068,
              7.0349
            ],
            [
              2069,
              7.0273
            ],
            [
              2070,
              7.0877
            ],
            [
              2071,
              7.0964
            ],
            [
              2072,
              7.0417
            ],
            [
              2073,
              7.0302
            ],
            [
              2074,
              7.0614
            ],
            [
              2075,
              7.1363
            ],
            [
              2076,
              7.0924
            ],
            [
              2077,
              7.1185
            ],
            [
              2078,
              7.1664
            ],
            [
              2079,
              7.2397
            ],
            [
              2080,
              7.3365
            ],
            [
              2081,
              7.2453
            ],
            [
              2082,
              6.9751
            ],
            [
              2083,
              6.7727
            ],
            [
              2084,
              6.6285
            ],
            [
              2085,
              6.5313
            ],
            [
              2086,
              6.4752
            ],
            [
              2087,
              6.4494
            ],
            [
              2088,
              6.4522
            ],
            [
              2089,
              6.4839
            ],
            [
              2090,
              6.0563
            ],
            [
              2091,
              6.4615
            ],
            [
              2092,
              6.2876
            ],
            [
              2093,
              6.1891
            ],
            [
              2094,
              6.1541
            ],
            [
              2095,
              6.1768
            ],
            [
              2096,
              6.2134
            ],
            [
              2097,
              6.2486
            ],
            [
              2098,
              6.3245
            ],
            [
              2099,
              6.4446
            ],
            [
              2100,
              6.3724
            ]
          ],
          "lower": [
            [
              2020,
              6.0086
            ],
            [
              2021,
              5.9289
            ],
            [
              2022,
              5.7928
            ],
            [
              2023,
              5.6496
            ],
            [
              2024,
              5.5367
            ],
            [
              2025,
              5.4637
            ],
            [
              2026,
              5.4283
            ],
            [
              2027,
              5.4284
            ],
            [
              2028,
              5.4637
            ],
            [
              2029,
              5.5306
            ],
            [
              2030,
              5.6135
            ],
            [
              2031,
              5.6838
            ],
            [
              2032,
              5.7353
            ],
            [
              2033,
              5.7905
            ],
            [
              2034,
              5.8623
            ],
            [
              2035,
              5.9499
            ],
            [
              2036,
              6.0492
            ],
            [
              2037,
              6.1761
            ],
            [
              2038,
              6.3218
            ],
            [
              2039,
              6.4645
            ],
            [
              2040,
              6.5698
            ],
            [
              2041,
              6.6019
            ],
            [
              2042,
              6.5778
            ],
            [
              2043,
              6.5572
            ],
            [
              2044,
              6.5714
            ],
            [
              2045,
              6.6203
            ],
            [
              2046,
              6.6836
            ],
            [
              2047,
              6.7468
            ],
            [
              2048,
              6.8077
            ],
            [
              2049,
              6.8521
            ],
            [
              2050,
              6.8377
            ],
            [
              2051,
              6.7061
            ],
            [
              2052,
              6.4768
            ],
            [
              2053,
              6.2345
            ],
            [
              2054,
              6.0276
            ],
            [
              2055,
              5.8668
            ],
            [
              2056,
              5.7451
            ],
            [
              2057,
              5.6545
            ],
            [
              2058,
              5.5906
            ],
            [
              2059,
              5.5416
            ],
            [
              2060,
              5.4969
            ],
            [
              2061,
              5.4888
            ],
            [
              2062,
              5.4494
            ],
            [
              2063,
              5.3845
            ],
            [
              2064,
              5.309
            ],
            [
              2065,
              5.2253
            ],
            [
              2066,
              5.129
            ],
            [
              2067,
              5.0324
            ],
            [
              2068,
              4.9618
            ],
            [
              2069,
              4.9254
            ],
            [
              2070,
              4.9123
            ],
            [
              2071,
              4.8987
            ],
            [
              2072,
              4.8784
            ],
            [
              2073,
              4.8644
            ],
            [
              2074,
              4.8622
            ],
            [
              2075,
              4.8646
            ],
            [
              2076,
              4.8599
            ],
            [
              2077,
              4.8621
            ],
            [
              2078,
              4.8749
            ],
            [
              2079,
              4.8903
            ],
            [
              2080,
              4.8848
            ],
            [
              2081,
              4.8261
            ],
            [
              2082,
              4.7194
            ],
            [
              2083,
              4.6053
            ],
            [
              2084,
              4.5092
            ],
            [
              2085,
              4.4383
            ],
            [
              2086,
              4.3907
            ],
            [
              2087,
              4.3594
            ],
            [
              2088,
              4.3329
            ],
            [
              2089,
              4.2968
            ],
            [
              2090,
              4.2499
            ],
            [
              2091,
              4.2575
            ],
            [
              2092,
              4.2398
            ],
            [
              2093,
              4.2111
            ],
            [
              2094,
              4.1943
            ],
            [
              2095,
              4.1976
            ],
            [
              2096,
              4.2165
            ],
            [
              2097,
              4.2465
            ],
            [
              2098,
              4.2854
            ],
            [
              2099,
              4.3217
            ],
            [
              2100,
              4.3395
            ]
          ],
          "upper": [
            [
              2020,
              7.2729
            ],
            [
              2021,
              7.1813
            ],
            [
              2022,
              7.0307
            ],
            [
              2023,
              6.9034
            ],
            [
              2024,
              6.8362
            ],
            [
              2025,
              6.8267
            ],
            [
              2026,
              6.8649
            ],
            [
              2027,
              6.9464
            ],
            [
              2028,
              7.0715
            ],
            [
              2029,
              7.2359
            ],
            [
              2030,
              7.4185
            ],
            [
              2031,
              7.5783
            ],
            [
              2032,
              7.7123
            ],
            [
              2033,
              7.8609
            ],
            [
              2034,
              8.0424
            ],
            [
              2035,
              8.2522
            ],
            [
              2036,
              8.4799
            ],
            [
              2037,
              8.7511
            ],
            [
              2038,
              9.0548
            ],
            [
              2039,
              9.366
            ],
            [
              2040,
              9.6352
            ],
            [
              2041,
              9.7965
            ],
            [
              2042,
              9.8757
            ],
            [
              2043,
              9.9787
            ],
            [
              2044,
              10.1513
            ],
            [
              2045,
              10.3869
            ],
            [
              2046,
              10.6443
            ],
            [
              2047,
              10.8964
            ],
            [
              2048,
              11.1472
            ],
            [
              2049,
              11.3776
            ],
            [
              2050,
              11.4996
            ],
            [
              2051,
              11.3605
            ],
            [
              2052,
              11.0076
            ],
            [
              2053,
              10.6446
            ],
            [
              2054,
              10.3621
            ],
            [
              2055,
              10.1664
            ],
            [
              2056,
              10.0384
            ],
            [
              2057,
              9.9636
            ],
            [
              2058,
              9.9421
            ],
            [
              2059,
              9.9485
            ],
            [
              2060,
              9.9504
            ],
            [
              2061,
              10.0469
            ],
            [
              2062,
              10.0475
            ],
            [
              2063,
              9.9932
            ],
            [
              2064,
              9.9286
            ],
            [
              2065,
              9.8516
            ],
            [
              2066,
              9.7339
            ],
            [
              2067,
              9.6007
            ],
            [
              2068,
              9.5231
            ],
            [
              2069,
              9.5218
            ],
            [
              2070,
              9.5664
            ],
            [
              2071,
              9.5881
            ],
            [
              2072,
              9.5752
            ],
            [
              2073,
              9.5782
            ],
            [
              2074,
              9.6168
            ],
            [
              2075,
              9.6696
            ],
            [
              2076,
              9.6945
            ],
            [
              2077,
              9.7348
            ],
            [
              2078,
              9.8028
            ],
            [
              2079,
              9.884
            ],
            [
              2080,
              9.9164
            ],
            [
              2081,
              9.7901
            ],
            [
              2082,
              9.5252
            ],
            [
              2083,
              9.2579
            ],
            [
              2084,
              9.0507
            ],
            [
              2085,
              8.9107
            ],
            [
              2086,
              8.8277
            ],
            [
              2087,
              8.787
            ],
            [
              2088,
              8.7635
            ],
            [
              2089,
              8.7102
            ],
            [
              2090,
              8.6033
            ],
            [
              2091,
              8.6715
            ],
            [
              2092,
              8.6303
            ],
            [
              2093,
              8.5547
            ],
            [
              2094,
              8.5188
            ],
            [
              2095,
              8.5381
            ],
            [
              2096,
              8.591
            ],
            [
              2097,
              8.6659
            ],
            [
              2098,
              8.7668
            ],
            [
              2099,
              8.8637
            ],
            [
              2100,
              8.8981
            ]
          ]
        },
        "s1a": {
          "median": [
            [
              2020,
              6.582
            ],
            [
              2021,
              6.7627
            ],
            [
              2022,
              6.3786
            ],
            [
              2023,
              6.1174
            ],
            [
              2024,
              5.9423
            ],
            [
              2025,
              5.8333
            ],
            [
              2026,
              5.7814
            ],
            [
              2027,
              5.782
            ],
            [
              2028,
              5.8347
            ],
            [
              2029,
              5.9408
            ],
            [
              2030,
              6.1054
            ],
            [
              2031,
              6.2008
            ],
            [
              2032,
              6.1799
            ],
            [
              2033,
              6.1951
            ],
            [
              2034,
              6.243
            ],
            [
              2035,
              6.3227
            ],
            [
              2036,
              6.368
            ],
            [
              2037,
              6.49
            ],
            [
              2038,
              6.6365
            ],
            [
              2039,
              6.8076
            ],
            [
              2040,
              6.9996
            ],
            [
              2041,
              7.1654
            ],
            [
              2042,
              7.2762
            ],
            [
              2043,
              7.3902
            ],
            [
              2044,
              7.4959
            ],
            [
              2045,
              7.6042
            ],
            [
              2046,
              7.5663
            ],
            [
              2047,
              7.4254
            ],
            [
              2048,
              7.3327
            ],
            [
              2049,
              7.2732
            ],
            [
              2050,
              7.2493
            ],
            [
              2051,
              7.1868
            ],
            [
              2052,
              7.1027
            ],
            [
              2053,
              7.0957
            ],
            [
              2054,
              7.1627
            ],
            [
              2055,
              7.3058
            ],
            [
              2056,
              7.4271
            ],
            [
              2057,
              7.4619
            ],
            [
              2058,
              7.552
            ],
            [
              2059,
              7.6983
            ],
            [
              2060,
              7.6725
            ],
            [
              2061,
              8.0098
            ],
            [
              2062,
              8.0662
            ],
            [
              2063,
              8.163
            ],
            [
              2064,
              8.3038
            ],
            [
              2065,
              8.4895
            ],
            [
              2066,
              8.656
            ],
            [
              2067,
              8.7638
            ],
            [
              2068,
              8.8768
            ],
            [
              2069,
              8.9964
            ],
            [
              2070,
              9.1242
            ],
            [
              2071,
              8.9799
            ],
            [
              2072,
              8.64
            ],
            [
              2073,
              8.3989
            ],
            [
              2074,
              8.2407
            ],
            [
              2075,
              8.2516
            ],
            [
              2076,
              8.0843
            ],
            [
              2077,
              8.0798
            ],
            [
              2078,
              8.1537
            ],
            [
              2079,
              8.3088
            ],
            [
              2080,
              8.5516
            ],
            [
              2081,
              8.6734
            ],
            [
              2082,
              8.571
            ],
            [
              2083,
              8.5328
            ],
            [
              2084,
              8.5593
            ],
            [
              2085,
              8.6528
            ],
            [
              2086,
              8.7276
            ],
            [
              2087,
              8.7695
            ],
            [
              2088,
              8.8619
            ],
            [
              2089,
              9.0089
            ],
            [
              2090,
              8.5504
            ],
            [
              2091,
              9.3151
            ],
            [
              2092,
              9.2766
            ],
            [
              2093,
              9.2703
            ],
            [
              2094,
              9.2964
            ],
            [
              2095,
              9.3568
            ],
            [
              2096,
              9.1853
            ],
            [
              2097,
              8.858
            ],
            [
              2098,
              8.6387
            ],
            [
              2099,
              8.5137
            ],
            [
              2100,
              8.1857
            ]
          ],
          "lower": [
            [
              2020,
              5.7553
            ],
            [
              2021,
              5.6204
            ],
            [
              2022,
              5.4567
            ],
            [
              2023,
              5.2925
            ],
            [
              2024,
              5.1567
            ],
            [
              2025,
              5.0648
            ],
            [
              2026,
              5.0212
            ],
            [
              2027,
              5.0243
            ],
            [
              2028,
              5.0678
            ],
            [
              2029,
              5.139
            ],
            [
              2030,
              5.2157
            ],
            [
              2031,
              5.27
            ],
            [
              2032,
              5.2931
            ],
            [
              2033,
              5.3014
            ],
            [
              2034,
              5.311
            ],
            [
              2035,
              5.3307
            ],
            [
              2036,
              5.3647
            ],
            [
              2037,
              5.4216
            ],
            [
              2038,
              5.5012
            ],
            [
              2039,
              5.5983
            ],
            [
              2040,
              5.7033
            ],
            [
              2041,
              5.8042
            ],
            [
              2042,
              5.8938
            ],
            [
              2043,
              5.9706
            ],
            [
              2044,
              6.0293
            ],
            [
              2045,
              6.0579
            ],
            [
              2046,
              6.0435
            ],
            [
              2047,
              5.994
            ],
            [
              2048,
              5.9323
            ],
            [
              2049,
              5.8721
            ],
            [
              2050,
              5.8163
            ],
            [
              2051,
              5.763
            ],
            [
              2052,
              5.7199
            ],
            [
              2053,
              5.7016
            ],
            [
              2054,
              5.7135
            ],
            [
              2055,
              5.7469
            ],
            [
              2056,
              5.7845
            ],
            [
              2057,
              5.8174
            ],
            [
              2058,
              5.8524
            ],
            [
              2059,
              5.8942
            ],
            [
              2060,
              5.943
            ],
            [
              2061,
              6.0092
            ],
            [
              2062,
              6.0694
            ],
            [
              2063,
              6.1277
            ],
            [
              2064,
              6.1919
            ],
            [
              2065,
              6.2627
            ],
            [
              2066,
              6.3333
            ],
            [
              2067,
              6.3975
            ],
            [
              2068,
              6.4524
            ],
            [
              2069,
              6.4883
            ],
            [
              2070,
              6.4849
            ],
            [
              2071,
              6.4221
            ],
            [
              2072,
              6.3136
            ],
            [
              2073,
              6.1996
            ],
            [
              2074,
              6.1085
            ],
            [
              2075,
              6.0495
            ],
            [
              2076,
              6.0156
            ],
            [
              2077,
              6.0194
            ],
            [
              2078,
              6.0627
            ],
            [
              2079,
              6.1345
            ],
            [
              2080,
              6.2098
            ],
            [
              2081,
              6.2572
            ],
            [
              2082,
              6.2686
            ],
            [
              2083,
              6.268
            ],
            [
              2084,
              6.276
            ],
            [
              2085,
              6.2981
            ],
            [
              2086,
              6.327
            ],
            [
              2087,
              6.356
            ],
            [
              2088,
              6.384
            ],
            [
              2089,
              6.4094
            ],
            [
              2090,
              6.4404
            ],
            [
              2091,
              6.5206
            ],
            [
              2092,
              6.5823
            ],
            [
              2093,
              6.6152
            ],
            [
              2094,
              6.6211
            ],
            [
              2095,
              6.5933
            ],
            [
              2096,
              6.5188
            ],
            [
              2097,
              6.408
            ],
            [
              2098,
              6.2862
            ],
            [
              2099,
              6.1619
            ],
            [
              2100,
              6.0289
            ]
          ],
          "upper": [
            [
              2020,
              6.8209
            ],
            [
              2021,
              6.6633
            ],
            [
              2022,
              6.4966
            ],
            [
              2023,
              6.3484
            ],
            [
              2024,
              6.2429
            ],
            [
              2025,
              6.1891
            ],
            [
              2026,
              6.1866
            ],
            [
              2027,
              6.2312
            ],
            [
              2028,
              6.3162
            ],
            [
              2029,
              6.4293
            ],
            [
              2030,
              6.5493
            ],
            [
              2031,
              6.6496
            ],
            [
              2032,
              6.7247
            ],
            [
              2033,
              6.7951
            ],
            [
              2034,
              6.877
            ],
            [
              2035,
              6.9761
            ],
            [
              2036,
              7.0931
            ],
            [
              2037,
              7.2345
            ],
            [
              2038,
              7.3973
            ],
            [
              2039,
              7.5735
            ],
            [
              2040,
              7.7508
            ],
            [
              2041,
              7.9154
            ],
            [
              2042,
              8.0617
            ],
            [
              2043,
              8.1932
            ],
            [
              2044,
              8.3066
            ],
            [
              2045,
              8.3886
            ],
            [
              2046,
              8.4222
            ],
            [
              2047,
              8.4173
            ],
            [
              2048,
              8.4039
            ],
            [
              2049,
              8.3985
            ],
            [
              2050,
              8.4022
            ],
            [
              2051,
              8.4096
            ],
            [
              2052,
              8.4317
            ],
            [
              2053,
              8.4921
            ],
            [
              2054,
              8.5995
            ],
            [
              2055,
              8.7417
            ],
            [
              2056,
              8.891
            ],
            [
              2057,
              9.0315
            ],
            [
              2058,
              9.1716
            ],
            [
              2059,
              9.3145
            ],
            [
              2060,
              9.4572
            ],
            [
              2061,
              9.6174
            ],
            [
              2062,
              9.7572
            ],
            [
              2063,
              9.8883
            ],
            [
              2064,
              10.0269
            ],
            [
              2065,
              10.1756
            ],
            [
              2066,
              10.3229
            ],
            [
              2067,
              10.4599
            ],
            [
              2068,
              10.5851
            ],
            [
              2069,
              10.6846
            ],
            [
              2070,
              10.724
            ],
            [
              2071,
              10.6645
            ],
            [
              2072,
              10.528
            ],
            [
              2073,
              10.3842
            ],
            [
              2074,
              10.2799
            ],
            [
              2075,
              10.2265
            ],
            [
              2076,
              10.2071
            ],
            [
              2077,
              10.2452
            ],
            [
              2078,
              10.3458
            ],
            [
              2079,
              10.4906
            ],
            [
              2080,
              10.6344
            ],
            [
              2081,
              10.7173
            ],
            [
              2082,
              10.7267
            ],
            [
              2083,
              10.7138
            ],
            [
              2084,
              10.719
            ],
            [
              2085,
              10.7523
            ],
            [
              2086,
              10.7993
            ],
            [
              2087,
              10.8483
            ],
            [
              2088,
              10.8972
            ],
            [
              2089,
              10.9414
            ],
            [
              2090,
              10.9929
            ],
            [
              2091,
              11.1371
            ],
            [
              2092,
              11.244
            ],
            [
              2093,
              11.3022
            ],
            [
              2094,
              11.322
            ],
            [
              2095,
              11.2927
            ],
            [
              2096,
              11.1875
            ],
            [
              2097,
              11.0238
            ],
            [
              2098,
              10.8475
            ],
            [
              2099,
              10.6703
            ],
            [
              2100,
              10.4759
            ]
          ]
        },
        "s2m": {
          "median": [
            [
              2020,
              7.2789
            ],
            [
              2021,
              7.6456
            ],
            [
              2022,
              7.4857
            ],
            [
              2023,
              7.3541
            ],
            [
              2024,
              7.2444
            ],
            [
              2025,
              7.1547
            ],
            [
              2026,
              7.0812
            ],
            [
              2027,
              7.0223
            ],
            [
              2028,
              6.9787
            ],
            [
              2029,
              6.9502
            ],
            [
              2030,
              6.9344
            ],
            [
              2031,
              6.8202
            ],
            [
              2032,
              6.7308
            ],
            [
              2033,
              6.6543
            ],
            [
              2034,
              6.5903
            ],
            [
              2035,
              6.539
            ],
            [
              2036,
              6.4592
            ],
            [
              2037,
              6.4436
            ],
            [
              2038,
              6.4429
            ],
            [
              2039,
              6.4575
            ],
            [
              2040,
              6.4833
            ],
            [
              2041,
              6.4899
            ],
            [
              2042,
              6.4516
            ],
            [
              2043,
              6.4072
            ],
            [
              2044,
              6.3589
            ],
            [
              2045,
              6.3097
            ],
            [
              2046,
              6.2387
            ],
            [
              2047,
              6.1576
            ],
            [
              2048,
              6.089
            ],
            [
              2049,
              6.0339
            ],
            [
              2050,
              5.9914
            ],
            [
              2051,
              5.9499
            ],
            [
              2052,
              5.8971
            ],
            [
              2053,
              5.8474
            ],
            [
              2054,
              5.8021
            ],
            [
              2055,
              5.7599
            ],
            [
              2056,
              5.6647
            ],
            [
              2057,
              5.5971
            ],
            [
              2058,
              5.5422
            ],
            [
              2059,
              5.5001
            ],
            [
              2060,
              5.3871
            ],
            [
              2061,
              5.4321
            ],
            [
              2062,
              5.4132
            ],
            [
              2063,
              5.4133
            ],
            [
              2064,
              5.4314
            ],
            [
              2065,
              5.4631
            ],
            [
              2066,
              5.5041
            ],
            [
              2067,
              5.5377
            ],
            [
              2068,
              5.5745
            ],
            [
              2069,
              5.6138
            ],
            [
              2070,
              5.6548
            ],
            [
              2071,
              5.6686
            ],
            [
              2072,
              5.6599
            ],
            [
              2073,
              5.6589
            ],
            [
              2074,
              5.6644
            ],
            [
              2075,
              5.7044
            ],
            [
              2076,
              5.633
            ],
            [
              2077,
              5.6646
            ],
            [
              2078,
              5.7032
            ],
            [
              2079,
              5.748
            ],
            [
              2080,
              5.795
            ],
            [
              2081,
              5.7863
            ],
            [
              2082,
              5.7839
            ],
            [
              2083,
              5.7868
            ],
            [
              2084,
              5.7936
            ],
            [
              2085,
              5.8036
            ],
            [
              2086,
              5.8167
            ],
            [
              2087,
              5.8348
            ],
            [
              2088,
              5.8546
            ],
            [
              2089,
              5.8747
            ],
            [
              2090,
              5.7266
            ],
            [
              2091,
              5.8921
            ],
            [
              2092,
              5.877
            ],
            [
              2093,
              5.8719
            ],
            [
              2094,
              5.8757
            ],
            [
              2095,
              5.8867
            ],
            [
              2096,
              5.8884
            ],
            [
              2097,
              5.8841
            ],
            [
              2098,
              5.8921
            ],
            [
              2099,
              5.9119
            ],
            [
              2100,
              5.8683
            ]
          ],
          "lower": [
            [
              2020,
              6.0968
            ],
            [
              2021,
              6.0509
            ],
            [
              2022,
              5.9865
            ],
            [
              2023,
              5.9066
            ],
            [
              2024,
              5.82
            ],
            [
              2025,
              5.7354
            ],
            [
              2026,
              5.6583
            ],
            [
              2027,
              5.5909
            ],
            [
              2028,
              5.5322
            ],
            [
              2029,
              5.4777
            ],
            [
              2030,
              5.4212
            ],
            [
              2031,
              5.3573
            ],
            [
              2032,
              5.2877
            ],
            [
              2033,
              5.2159
            ],
            [
              2034,
              5.1457
            ],
            [
              2035,
              5.0802
            ],
            [
              2036,
              5.0227
            ],
            [
              2037,
              4.9768
            ],
            [
              2038,
              4.9418
            ],
            [
              2039,
              4.9138
            ],
            [
              2040,
              4.8864
            ],
            [
              2041,
              4.8524
            ],
            [
              2042,
              4.8072
            ],
            [
              2043,
              4.7507
            ],
            [
              2044,
              4.6851
            ],
            [
              2045,
              4.6134
            ],
            [
              2046,
              4.5388
            ],
            [
              2047,
              4.4654
            ],
            [
              2048,
              4.3969
            ],
            [
              2049,
              4.3352
            ],
            [
              2050,
              4.2795
            ],
            [
              2051,
              4.2272
            ],
            [
              2052,
              4.1753
            ],
            [
              2053,
              4.1222
            ],
            [
              2054,
              4.0673
            ],
            [
              2055,
              4.0104
            ],
            [
              2056,
              3.9524
            ],
            [
              2057,
              3.8969
            ],
            [
              2058,
              3.8469
            ],
            [
              2059,
              3.8046
            ],
            [
              2060,
              3.7718
            ],
            [
              2061,
              3.7517
            ],
            [
              2062,
              3.7412
            ],
            [
              2063,
              3.7388
            ],
            [
              2064,
              3.7433
            ],
            [
              2065,
              3.7529
            ],
            [
              2066,
              3.7656
            ],
            [
              2067,
              3.7794
            ],
            [
              2068,
              3.7927
            ],
            [
              2069,
              3.8042
            ],
            [
              2070,
              3.8127
            ],
            [
              2071,
              3.8176
            ],
            [
              2072,
              3.8197
            ],
            [
              2073,
              3.821
            ],
            [
              2074,
              3.8228
            ],
            [
              2075,
              3.8255
            ],
            [
              2076,
              3.8289
            ],
            [
              2077,
              3.8362
            ],
            [
              2078,
              3.8466
            ],
            [
              2079,
              3.8575
            ],
            [
              2080,
              3.8659
            ],
            [
              2081,
              3.8702
            ],
            [
              2082,
              3.8717
            ],
            [
              2083,
              3.8727
            ],
            [
              2084,
              3.8744
            ],
            [
              2085,
              3.8775
            ],
            [
              2086,
              3.8814
            ],
            [
              2087,
              3.8853
            ],
            [
              2088,
              3.8878
            ],
            [
              2089,
              3.8885
            ],
            [
              2090,
              3.8891
            ],
            [
              2091,
              3.8949
            ],
            [
              2092,
              3.9011
            ],
            [
              2093,
              3.9066
            ],
            [
              2094,
              3.9119
            ],
            [
              2095,
              3.9172
            ],
            [
              2096,
              3.9224
            ],
            [
              2097,
              3.9275
            ],
            [
              2098,
              3.9326
            ],
            [
              2099,
              3.9369
            ],
            [
              2100,
              3.9398
            ]
          ],
          "upper": [
            [
              2020,
              7.5756
            ],
            [
              2021,
              7.5102
            ],
            [
              2022,
              7.436
            ],
            [
              2023,
              7.3773
            ],
            [
              2024,
              7.3233
            ],
            [
              2025,
              7.2772
            ],
            [
              2026,
              7.2424
            ],
            [
              2027,
              7.2184
            ],
            [
              2028,
              7.2018
            ],
            [
              2029,
              7.1869
            ],
            [
              2030,
              7.1673
            ],
            [
              2031,
              7.1397
            ],
            [
              2032,
              7.1109
            ],
            [
              2033,
              7.0876
            ],
            [
              2034,
              7.0738
            ],
            [
              2035,
              7.0715
            ],
            [
              2036,
              7.0821
            ],
            [
              2037,
              7.1088
            ],
            [
              2038,
              7.1492
            ],
            [
              2039,
              7.1975
            ],
            [
              2040,
              7.2454
            ],
            [
              2041,
              7.2843
            ],
            [
              2042,
              7.3092
            ],
            [
              2043,
              7.3211
            ],
            [
              2044,
              7.3222
            ],
            [
              2045,
              7.3142
            ],
            [
              2046,
              7.2983
            ],
            [
              2047,
              7.2779
            ],
            [
              2048,
              7.2573
            ],
            [
              2049,
              7.2389
            ],
            [
              2050,
              7.2219
            ],
            [
              2051,
              7.2032
            ],
            [
              2052,
              7.18
            ],
            [
              2053,
              7.1515
            ],
            [
              2054,
              7.1166
            ],
            [
              2055,
              7.0735
            ],
            [
              2056,
              7.0223
            ],
            [
              2057,
              6.9693
            ],
            [
              2058,
              6.9194
            ],
            [
              2059,
              6.876
            ],
            [
              2060,
              6.8433
            ],
            [
              2061,
              6.8299
            ],
            [
              2062,
              6.8306
            ],
            [
              2063,
              6.8443
            ],
            [
              2064,
              6.87
            ],
            [
              2065,
              6.9056
            ],
            [
              2066,
              6.9476
            ],
            [
              2067,
              6.9922
            ],
            [
              2068,
              7.0366
            ],
            [
              2069,
              7.0779
            ],
            [
              2070,
              7.113
            ],
            [
              2071,
              7.1391
            ],
            [
              2072,
              7.158
            ],
            [
              2073,
              7.1743
            ],
            [
              2074,
              7.1911
            ],
            [
              2075,
              7.209
            ],
            [
              2076,
              7.2273
            ],
            [
              2077,
              7.2548
            ],
            [
              2078,
              7.29
            ],
            [
              2079,
              7.3268
            ],
            [
              2080,
              7.3577
            ],
            [
              2081,
              7.3785
            ],
            [
              2082,
              7.3937
            ],
            [
              2083,
              7.4085
            ],
            [
              2084,
              7.426
            ],
            [
              2085,
              7.4468
            ],
            [
              2086,
              7.4696
            ],
            [
              2087,
              7.4911
            ],
            [
              2088,
              7.5076
            ],
            [
              2089,
              7.5172
            ],
            [
              2090,
              7.5237
            ],
            [
              2091,
              7.5428
            ],
            [
              2092,
              7.5607
            ],
            [
              2093,
              7.5757
            ],
            [
              2094,
              7.5896
            ],
            [
              2095,
              7.6037
            ],
            [
              2096,
              7.6176
            ],
            [
              2097,
              7.6316
            ],
            [
              2098,
              7.6456
            ],
            [
              2099,
              7.6575
            ],
            [
              2100,
              7.6652
            ]
          ]
        },
        "s5r": {
          "median": [
            [
              2020,
              6.9065
            ],
            [
              2021,
              7.2362
            ],
            [
              2022,
              7.142
            ],
            [
              2023,
              7.0506
            ],
            [
              2024,
              6.964
            ],
            [
              2025,
              6.8836
            ],
            [
              2026,
              6.8085
            ],
            [
              2027,
              6.7402
            ],
            [
              2028,
              6.6797
            ],
            [
              2029,
              6.6272
            ],
            [
              2030,
              6.5814
            ],
            [
              2031,
              6.4475
            ],
            [
              2032,
              6.2918
            ],
            [
              2033,
              6.1605
            ],
            [
              2034,
              6.052
            ],
            [
              2035,
              5.964
            ],
            [
              2036,
              5.86
            ],
            [
              2037,
              5.8045
            ],
            [
              2038,
              5.7632
            ],
            [
              2039,
              5.7346
            ],
            [
              2040,
              5.7162
            ],
            [
              2041,
              5.6302
            ],
            [
              2042,
              5.4852
            ],
            [
              2043,
              5.3671
            ],
            [
              2044,
              5.2748
            ],
            [
              2045,
              5.1885
            ],
            [
              2046,
              5.1645
            ],
            [
              2047,
              5.1457
            ],
            [
              2048,
              5.1527
            ],
            [
              2049,
              5.1872
            ],
            [
              2050,
              5.2511
            ],
            [
              2051,
              5.2934
            ],
            [
              2052,
              5.296
            ],
            [
              2053,
              5.3064
            ],
            [
              2054,
              5.3249
            ],
            [
              2055,
              5.3502
            ],
            [
              2056,
              5.3577
            ],
            [
              2057,
              5.3795
            ],
            [
              2058,
              5.4149
            ],
            [
              2059,
              5.4643
            ],
            [
              2060,
              5.4583
            ],
            [
              2061,
              5.5726
            ],
            [
              2062,
              5.6116
            ],
            [
              2063,
              5.6523
            ],
            [
              2064,
              5.6953
            ],
            [
              2065,
              5.7399
            ],
            [
              2066,
              5.7684
            ],
            [
              2067,
              5.7796
            ],
            [
              2068,
              5.7942
            ],
            [
              2069,
              5.8125
            ],
            [
              2070,
              5.835
            ],
            [
              2071,
              5.8389
            ],
            [
              2072,
              5.8297
            ],
            [
              2073,
              5.8311
            ],
            [
              2074,
              5.8434
            ],
            [
              2075,
              5.883
            ],
            [
              2076,
              5.8998
            ],
            [
              2077,
              5.923
            ],
            [
              2078,
              5.9564
            ],
            [
              2079,
              6.0008
            ],
            [
              2080,
              6.0551
            ],
            [
              2081,
              6.0565
            ],
            [
              2082,
              6.0385
            ],
            [
              2083,
              6.041
            ],
            [
              2084,
              6.0627
            ],
            [
              2085,
              6.0845
            ],
            [
              2086,
              6.1601
            ],
            [
              2087,
              6.2318
            ],
            [
              2088,
              6.3184
            ],
            [
              2089,
              6.4201
            ],
            [
              2090,
              6.3921
            ],
            [
              2091,
              6.6022
            ],
            [
              2092,
              6.6083
            ],
            [
              2093,
              6.6213
            ],
            [
              2094,
              6.6409
            ],
            [
              2095,
              6.6672
            ],
            [
              2096,
              6.7014
            ],
            [
              2097,
              6.7463
            ],
            [
              2098,
              6.7983
            ],
            [
              2099,
              6.8573
            ],
            [
              2100,
              6.8497
            ]
          ],
          "lower": [
            [
              2020,
              5.7887
            ],
            [
              2021,
              5.7965
            ],
            [
              2022,
              5.8038
            ],
            [
              2023,
              5.793
            ],
            [
              2024,
              5.7693
            ],
            [
              2025,
              5.7408
            ],
            [
              2026,
              5.7127
            ],
            [
              2027,
              5.6868
            ],
            [
              2028,
              5.6607
            ],
            [
              2029,
              5.6262
            ],
            [
              2030,
              5.5678
            ],
            [
              2031,
              5.4679
            ],
            [
              2032,
              5.3324
            ],
            [
              2033,
              5.1794
            ],
            [
              2034,
              5.0223
            ],
            [
              2035,
              4.8677
            ],
            [
              2036,
              4.7194
            ],
            [
              2037,
              4.5851
            ],
            [
              2038,
              4.4637
            ],
            [
              2039,
              4.3488
            ],
            [
              2040,
              4.2276
            ],
            [
              2041,
              4.0851
            ],
            [
              2042,
              3.9224
            ],
            [
              2043,
              3.7568
            ],
            [
              2044,
              3.6026
            ],
            [
              2045,
              3.4686
            ],
            [
              2046,
              3.3606
            ],
            [
              2047,
              3.2773
            ],
            [
              2048,
              3.2182
            ],
            [
              2049,
              3.1813
            ],
            [
              2050,
              3.1603
            ],
            [
              2051,
              3.1447
            ],
            [
              2052,
              3.1277
            ],
            [
              2053,
              3.1102
            ],
            [
              2054,
              3.0944
            ],
            [
              2055,
              3.0814
            ],
            [
              2056,
              3.0718
            ],
            [
              2057,
              3.0679
            ],
            [
              2058,
              3.0712
            ],
            [
              2059,
              3.0813
            ],
            [
              2060,
              3.0974
            ],
            [
              2061,
              3.1215
            ],
            [
              2062,
              3.1451
            ],
            [
              2063,
              3.1666
            ],
            [
              2064,
              3.1862
            ],
            [
              2065,
              3.2039
            ],
            [
              2066,
              3.2188
            ],
            [
              2067,
              3.2314
            ],
            [
              2068,
              3.2434
            ],
            [
              2069,
              3.2557
            ],
            [
              2070,
              3.2674
            ],
            [
              2071,
              3.2768
            ],
            [
              2072,
              3.2845
            ],
            [
              2073,
              3.293
            ],
            [
              2074,
              3.3043
            ],
            [
              2075,
              3.3187
            ],
            [
              2076,
              3.3343
            ],
            [
              2077,
              3.3521
            ],
            [
              2078,
              3.3728
            ],
            [
              2079,
              3.3957
            ],
            [
              2080,
              3.4177
            ],
            [
              2081,
              3.4344
            ],
            [
              2082,
              3.4476
            ],
            [
              2083,
              3.4623
            ],
            [
              2084,
              3.4816
            ],
            [
              2085,
              3.5073
            ],
            [
              2086,
              3.5406
            ],
            [
              2087,
              3.5783
            ],
            [
              2088,
              3.6178
            ],
            [
              2089,
              3.6559
            ],
            [
              2090,
              3.6908
            ],
            [
              2091,
              3.7292
            ],
            [
              2092,
              3.7572
            ],
            [
              2093,
              3.777
            ],
            [
              2094,
              3.7941
            ],
            [
              2095,
              3.8119
            ],
            [
              2096,
              3.8322
            ],
            [
              2097,
              3.8548
            ],
            [
              2098,
              3.8778
            ],
            [
              2099,
              3.8985
            ],
            [
              2100,
              3.915
            ]
          ],
          "upper": [
            [
              2020,
              7.1732
            ],
            [
              2021,
              7.1334
            ],
            [
              2022,
              7.0963
            ],
            [
              2023,
              7.0398
            ],
            [
              2024,
              6.968
            ],
            [
              2025,
              6.8913
            ],
            [
              2026,
              6.8179
            ],
            [
              2027,
              6.7511
            ],
            [
              2028,
              6.6894
            ],
            [
              2029,
              6.6248
            ],
            [
              2030,
              6.5785
            ],
            [
              2031,
              6.5111
            ],
            [
              2032,
              6.4312
            ],
            [
              2033,
              6.3541
            ],
            [
              2034,
              6.2875
            ],
            [
              2035,
              6.2317
            ],
            [
              2036,
              6.185
            ],
            [
              2037,
              6.1521
            ],
            [
              2038,
              6.1296
            ],
            [
              2039,
              6.1088
            ],
            [
              2040,
              6.0749
            ],
            [
              2041,
              6.0105
            ],
            [
              2042,
              5.9199
            ],
            [
              2043,
              5.8257
            ],
            [
              2044,
              5.7437
            ],
            [
              2045,
              5.6816
            ],
            [
              2046,
              5.6461
            ],
            [
              2047,
              5.6343
            ],
            [
              2048,
              5.6463
            ],
            [
              2049,
              5.6806
            ],
            [
              2050,
              5.7289
            ],
            [
              2051,
              5.775
            ],
            [
              2052,
              5.8116
            ],
            [
              2053,
              5.8454
            ],
            [
              2054,
              5.8817
            ],
            [
              2055,
              5.9209
            ],
            [
              2056,
              5.9622
            ],
            [
              2057,
              6.0092
            ],
            [
              2058,
              6.0635
            ],
            [
              2059,
              6.1229
            ],
            [
              2060,
              6.1857
            ],
            [
              2061,
              6.2604
            ],
            [
              2062,
              6.3293
            ],
            [
              2063,
              6.3919
            ],
            [
              2064,
              6.4504
            ],
            [
              2065,
              6.5045
            ],
            [
              2066,
              6.5512
            ],
            [
              2067,
              6.5912
            ],
            [
              2068,
              6.629
            ],
            [
              2069,
              6.6662
            ],
            [
              2070,
              6.7003
            ],
            [
              2071,
              6.7264
            ],
            [
              2072,
              6.7467
            ],
            [
              2073,
              6.7693
            ],
            [
              2074,
              6.7995
            ],
            [
              2075,
              6.8375
            ],
            [
              2076,
              6.8778
            ],
            [
              2077,
              6.9223
            ],
            [
              2078,
              6.9736
            ],
            [
              2079,
              7.0298
            ],
            [
              2080,
              7.082
            ],
            [
              2081,
              7.1181
            ],
            [
              2082,
              7.1434
            ],
            [
              2083,
              7.1719
            ],
            [
              2084,
              7.212
            ],
            [
              2085,
              7.2672
            ],
            [
              2086,
              7.3415
            ],
            [
              2087,
              7.4267
            ],
            [
              2088,
              7.5165
            ],
            [
              2089,
              7.6031
            ],
            [
              2090,
              7.6818
            ],
            [
              2091,
              7.772
            ],
            [
              2092,
              7.8343
            ],
            [
              2093,
              7.8765
            ],
            [
              2094,
              7.9129
            ],
            [
              2095,
              7.9524
            ],
            [
              2096,
              7.9985
            ],
            [
              2097,
              8.0506
            ],
            [
              2098,
              8.1043
            ],
            [
              2099,
              8.152
            ],
            [
              2100,
              8.1877
            ]
          ]
        }
      },
      "unit": "безразмерный EROI",
      "period": "published model 2020-2100; annual author-supplied tables",
      "region": "мир; вся энергосистема; конечная энергия",
      "status": "опубликованный результат сценарной модели, не наблюдение и не вероятность",
      "source_url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-022-33976-5",
      "source_locator": "Figure 4c; Methods equation for overall energy system EROI; released source workbooks",
      "source_version": "Nature Communications 13, 6932 (2022)",
      "access_date": "2026-09-22",
      "source_file": "source_cache/Slamersak_2022_EROIsys_Fig4.xlsx",
      "source_sha256": "393f1b1f76d636497d80c3d98814c6fb14a074e1c26f1a6f3dec6dd5c6c78922",
      "transformation": "Авторские ежегодные значения 2020-2100 перенесены без экстраполяции; интерфейс округляет до 0,1 и интерполирует только дробный год",
      "source_kind": "external_primary_or_official",
      "source_reference": "https://osf.io/v5nqg/?view_only=d28f6be45dc44dec884b0afa59098b76",
      "numerator_stage": "total final energy delivered to the point of use across electricity, gases, liquid fuels and solids",
      "denominator_stage": "energy used by the energy system from extraction through processing, conversion and delivery, including construction, operation, maintenance and decommissioning",
      "cost_composition": "direct on-site and indirect upstream energy for extraction, processing, conversion, transport, construction, operation, maintenance and decommissioning across 27 conversion technologies",
      "territory": "world",
      "status_source": "published scenario-model outputs for four illustrative 1.5°C-compatible pathways; not observations, probabilities or an unconditional forecast",
      "carriers": [
        "electricity",
        "gases",
        "liquid fuels",
        "solids"
      ],
      "source_verification": {
        "status": "local_primary_xlsx_cells_and_hashes_verified",
        "checked_on": "2026-09-22",
        "evidence": "Figure 4 workbook, sheet 'EROI of the energy system' A1:M97; Supplementary Figure 3 workbook, sheets LED/S1-A/S2-M/S5-R A1:H97",
        "sha256": "393f1b1f76d636497d80c3d98814c6fb14a074e1c26f1a6f3dec6dd5c6c78922",
        "additional_sha256": "deb941d4f2dd6c3cfacad73c8f3726bedc9e85a6b09ab6f4d6d959f91154f5a3",
        "local_evidence_files": [
          "source_cache/Slamersak_2022_EROIsys_Fig4.xlsx",
          "source_cache/Slamersak_2022_EROI_envelopes_SupFig3.xlsx"
        ]
      }
    }
  ],
  "source_vintages": {
    "Nature": "2024",
    "IEA_grids": "2023",
    "IEA_COP28": "2024",
    "UN_WPP": "WPP 2024 GEN/01/REV1; 2023 Estimates and 2050 Medium variant",
    "WDI": "API source 2; 2024 observations; API last updated 2026-07-13",
    "IMF_WEO": "not used; original vintage not independently obtained",
    "EI": "not used; original vintage not independently obtained",
    "IEA_EEI": "web methodology page updated 2026-07-17; no licensed dataset values embedded",
    "DLE_method": "Millward-Hopkins et al. 2020; method only",
    "Nature_EROI": "Nature Energy 2024; Figshare version 1, file 46240243"
  },
  "changes": [
    {
      "version": "I1",
      "change": "Услуги отделены от энергопотребления; ветви доступны без JS"
    },
    {
      "version": "I2",
      "change": "Рецензия NP176-I1: условные границы, линейный масштаб, правила v3, численные ссылки и адреса ветвей",
      "evidence": "iteration1_deepseek_review.txt"
    },
    {
      "version": "I3",
      "change": "Добавлены 7 сравнительных таблиц: генерация, накопители, термояд, сырьё, переработка, внедрение, экологические проверки; рецензия I2 заблокирована до отправки"
    },
    {
      "version": "I4",
      "change": "Семь отдельных колонок паспорта EROI; точная JSON-спецификация v3; исправлен контраст; правила классификации не изменены"
    },
    {
      "version": "I8",
      "change": "Добавлен количественный калькулятор физических услуг: население × охват × объём услуги × энергоёмкость; пустые входы остаются UNKNOWN, встроенного прогноза нет",
      "evidence": "service-demand-model.json; #service-demand; iteration8 tests pending"
    },
    {
      "version": "I9",
      "change": "Добавлены раздельные региональные таблицы населения/медианного возраста WPP 2024 и доступа к электричеству, безопасно управляемой воде и санитарии WDI за 2024 год; прогноз, оценки и наблюдения маркированы",
      "evidence": "population-access-data.json; #population-access; D14–D18; M08"
    },
    {
      "version": "I10",
      "change": "Добавлены раздельные конечный и полезный годовые ряды EROI мирового ископаемого энергомикса за 1971–2020; полные ячейки, границы и статус прогноза UNKNOWN",
      "evidence": "eroi-history-data.json; #eroi-history; build_i10_eroi_history.py; I10_REPRODUCE.md"
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-09-14",
      "build": "NP176-I11",
      "what": "Добавлены опубликованные границы лома меди, задержка срока службы, отдельный энергобенчмарк алюминия и условный массовый калькулятор.",
      "why": "Не выдавать массу металла в изделиях или доступный лом за фактический вторичный выход и не переносить энергозатраты одного материала на другой.",
      "evidence": [
        "D19",
        "D20",
        "D21",
        "M10"
      ]
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-09-14",
      "build": "NP176-I12",
      "what": "Год и EROI связаны только внутри одного из трёх выбранных опубликованных модельных маршрутов.",
      "why": "Устранить впечатление случайной независимости, не превращая учебную шкалу или исторический ряд ископаемого энергомикса в вымышленный прогноз.",
      "evidence": [
        "D22",
        "M11"
      ]
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-09-14",
      "build": "NP176-I13",
      "what": "Уточнено основание односторонней связи год→EROI; энергоёмкость переработки меди явно оставлена UNKNOWN; перечислены требования к воспроизводимому прогнозу.",
      "why": "Точно выполнить замечания независимой рецензии I12 без изменения траекторий и без автоматического повышения статусов.",
      "evidence": [
        "own_i12_deepseek_review.txt",
        "eroi-scenario-pathways.json",
        "recycling-boundaries-data.json",
        "#milestones",
        "#recycling-limits"
      ]
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-09-14",
      "build": "NP176-I14",
      "what": "Отозвана связь EROI электроэнергетики с общей шкалой; сценарный показатель отделён и снабжён долей электричества в конечном энергопотреблении.",
      "why": "EROI подсистемы, охватывающей около 21% мирового конечного энергопотребления, не представляет общий EROI энергетики.",
      "evidence": [
        "D22",
        "D23",
        "M11",
        "#milestones"
      ]
    },
    {
      "iteration": "I15",
      "change": "A falsification-first audit found D24 on PDF page 138, correcting the former blanket UNKNOWN for copper recycling energy. The source's 27/28 Mt internal discrepancy is now explicit. A complete scoped claim registry was added.",
      "why": "Scientific claims must survive source-level attempts at disproof; prior AI agreement and local tests did not reveal these source details.",
      "evidence": [
        "D19",
        "D24",
        "claim-registry.json",
        "scientific-method-protocol.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-09-15",
      "version": "NP176-I16-local",
      "change": "Primary-stage row added from the same released dataset; observed slider now updates Primary, Final and Useful values together; no inverse EROI-to-year mapping.",
      "reason": "A single EROI value per year concealed incompatible energy-stage boundaries."
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-09-15",
      "version": "NP176-I18-local",
      "change": "DeepSeek falsification review corrected the service model: the four rows are a partial demonstration basket; annual K_s is separated from continuous capability; required/N/A states, strict zero handling, vector and absolute deficits, and a dynamic EROI causal path were added.",
      "reason": "Annual allocated energy alone cannot establish firm capacity, timing, delivery or non-energy feasibility, and min(K_s) is only a Boolean all-required-rows test.",
      "evidence": [
        "service-demand-model.json",
        "scenario-rules.json",
        "i17_deepseek_review.txt"
      ]
    },
    {
      "version": "NP176-I20-local",
      "date": "2026-09-19",
      "summary": "Corrected inverse navigation on rounded pathways, preserved manual service overrides, aligned visible claim counts and model versions, and split methodology and service interpretation into dedicated pages.",
      "scientific_limits": [
        "Displayed pathway nodes remain approximate Figure 2 digitisation rounded to 0.1.",
        "The service calculator remains an annual partial-basket test, not a continuity forecast."
      ]
    },
    {
      "version": "NP176-I21-local",
      "date": "2026-09-19",
      "change": "Added a bounded quantitative technology example, UNECE life-cycle environmental cards, a dimensionless efficiency/rebound method, physical-money separation, systematic glossary links, and a visual marker for rounded flat scenario segments",
      "reason": "Independent DeepSeek I20 review: criteria 01, 16, 20, 29 and 30 failed; rounded plateau remained visually ambiguous"
    },
    {
      "version": "NP176-I22-local",
      "date": "2026-09-19",
      "change": "Added a reproducibility page, cell-level provenance completion, source-vintage ledger, clustering sensitivity audit and literal term links in scoped visible prose.",
      "reason": "Resolve scientific acceptance criteria without converting missing evidence into PASS.",
      "remaining_unknown": [
        "whole-energy forecast",
        "continuous reliability",
        "project deployment schedule"
      ]
    },
    {
      "version": "NP176-I24-candidate",
      "date": "2026-09-20",
      "summary": "I24 reopens or byte-verifies every active external source record, keeps obsolete D06 outside current calculations, and preserves method-specific verification labels."
    },
    {
      "version": "NP176-I27-candidate",
      "date": "2026-09-22",
      "what": "Added visible and machine-readable complete boundary passports for every displayed numerical EROI group after I26 independent review; numerical values unchanged.",
      "evidence": "eroi-boundary-passports.json; index.html; timeline.html; system.html; evidence.html"
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-09-22",
      "build": "NP176-I28-candidate",
      "what": "Основная связь год↔EROI переведена с электроэнергетики на всю энергосистему; прежняя модель сохранена на отдельной странице.",
      "why": "EROI подсистемы электроэнергетики не представлял общую энергетическую границу.",
      "evidence": [
        "D28",
        "eroi-whole-energy-pathways.json",
        "power-timeline.html"
      ]
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-09-22",
      "build": "NP176-FINAL-frozen",
      "what": "Исправлена классификация M09 как внутреннего воспроизводимого правила; уточнены 28 внешних записей: 27 активных и 1 архивная.",
      "why": "DeepSeek обнаружил расхождение 27/28; источник расхождения — ошибочный source_kind у M09, а не отсутствующая проверка D-записи.",
      "evidence": [
        "primary-source-audit.json",
        "provenance-audit.json",
        "audit.html"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "regional_datasets_used": [
    "UN WPP 2024 major regions",
    "World Bank WDI regional aggregates"
  ],
  "historical_eroi_dataset": {
    "data_file": "eroi-history-data.json",
    "source_cache": "source_cache/figshare_46240243_global_erois.csv",
    "source_sha256": "12241f109b0e1f540f591fbaec912961ea0b458365a029f7dae5396cfd10340d",
    "years": [
      1971,
      2020
    ],
    "annual_rows_per_stage": 50,
    "stages": [
      "Primary",
      "Final (fuel+elec+heat)",
      "Useful (fuel+elec+heat)"
    ],
    "missing_years": [],
    "interpolated_years": [],
    "forecast_status": "UNKNOWN"
  },
  "recycling_dataset": {
    "file": "recycling-boundaries-data.json",
    "source_file": "source_cache/IEA_Recycling_of_Critical_Minerals_rev_2025.pdf",
    "source_sha256": "bf54828d9f8b9e05646b0f22e5b1a4a9b183b590974974abe1824d4f053c3263",
    "published_records": [
      "D19",
      "D20",
      "D21",
      "D24"
    ],
    "calculation_contract": "M10",
    "scope": "Copper scrap flow and lifetimes; aluminium relative energy benchmark; boundaries remain separate.",
    "copper_process_energy_status": "UNKNOWN",
    "copper_energy_status": "D24: 15% relative industry-average benchmark; absolute and route-specific energy UNKNOWN",
    "source_internal_discrepancy": "2050 available scrap is 27 Mt in detailed page 83 and 28 Mt in revised executive page 11; both state 70% of demand"
  },
  "scenario_eroi_dataset": {
    "file": "eroi-scenario-pathways.json",
    "records": [
      "D22",
      "M11",
      "M12"
    ],
    "figure_sha256": "4e461931414fd7a79ffd81991bbe528db3b90838fdaa0dcc5073acfe4afcc44c",
    "boundary": "global power system, point of final electricity consumption",
    "status": "approximate figure digitisation",
    "control_direction": "year determines separate power-sector EROI; inverse control searches only the selected displayed line",
    "inverse_policy": "enabled as bounded selected-line navigation; non-unique results are reported as multiple points or a range",
    "whole_energy_scale_coupling": "PROHIBITED"
  },
  "complete_claim_registry_scope": "All substantive empirical, model, scenario, boundary and inference claims visible on the current public page; navigation labels and purely editorial aspirations are excluded.",
  "claim_registry_file": "claim-registry.json",
  "service_adequacy_model": {
    "version": "NP176-I21",
    "contract": "service-demand-model.json",
    "scenario_rules": "scenario-rules.json",
    "direct_indicator": "observed annual shortfall in a required row and separately observed delivery reliability",
    "annual_test": "necessary energy-balance check only; K_s >= 1 does not prove continuous capability",
    "row_policy": "required rows need strictly positive valid inputs; N/A excluded; unknown status returns UNKNOWN; no required rows returns NO_REQUIRED_SERVICE",
    "outputs": [
      "complete K_s vector",
      "number of shortfall rows",
      "absolute energy deficits",
      "physical service-unit deficits"
    ],
    "eroi_role": "upstream pressure indicator only; dynamic path is EROI -> net energy -> investment, maintenance and replacement -> future service capacity and reliability",
    "limitations": [
      "partial four-row demonstration basket only",
      "annual balance does not prove hourly or seasonal continuity",
      "capacity, networks, storage, reserves and infrastructure are separate inputs",
      "equipment, materials, labour, spatial access and vulnerable groups are not calculated",
      "user-defined minima are not universal thresholds"
    ],
    "manual_override": "A manual services value persists while the calculator continues to report its own result separately; automatic synchronisation resumes only after an explicit user action or scenario reset."
  },
  "scenario_eroi_dataset_whole_energy": {
    "file": "eroi-whole-energy-pathways.json",
    "records": [
      "D28"
    ],
    "figure_workbook_sha256": "393f1b1f76d636497d80c3d98814c6fb14a074e1c26f1a6f3dec6dd5c6c78922",
    "envelope_workbook_sha256": "deb941d4f2dd6c3cfacad73c8f3726bedc9e85a6b09ab6f4d6d959f91154f5a3"
  }
}