{ "schema_version": "1.0", "build": "NP176-FINAL-frozen", "policy": "Keep the original claim, correction, reason, evidence and residual uncertainty; do not erase adverse reviews.", "owner_policy_status": "General scientific rule approved on 2026-09-19; public author/contact remains unconfirmed.", "entries": [ { "version": "I1", "change": "Услуги отделены от энергопотребления; ветви доступны без JS" }, { "version": "I2", "change": "Рецензия NP176-I1: условные границы, линейный масштаб, правила v3, численные ссылки и адреса ветвей", "evidence": "iteration1_deepseek_review.txt" }, { "version": "I3", "change": "Добавлены 7 сравнительных таблиц: генерация, накопители, термояд, сырьё, переработка, внедрение, экологические проверки; рецензия I2 заблокирована до отправки" }, { "version": "I4", "change": "Семь отдельных колонок паспорта EROI; точная JSON-спецификация v3; исправлен контраст; правила классификации не изменены" }, { "version": "I8", "change": "Добавлен количественный калькулятор физических услуг: население × охват × объём услуги × энергоёмкость; пустые входы остаются UNKNOWN, встроенного прогноза нет", "evidence": "service-demand-model.json; #service-demand; iteration8 tests pending" }, { "version": "I9", "change": "Добавлены раздельные региональные таблицы населения/медианного возраста WPP 2024 и доступа к электричеству, безопасно управляемой воде и санитарии WDI за 2024 год; прогноз, оценки и наблюдения маркированы", "evidence": "population-access-data.json; #population-access; D14–D18; M08" }, { "version": "I10", "change": "Добавлены раздельные конечный и полезный годовые ряды EROI мирового ископаемого энергомикса за 1971–2020; полные ячейки, границы и статус прогноза UNKNOWN", "evidence": "eroi-history-data.json; #eroi-history; build_i10_eroi_history.py; I10_REPRODUCE.md" }, { "date": "2026-09-14", "build": "NP176-I11", "what": "Добавлены опубликованные границы лома меди, задержка срока службы, отдельный энергобенчмарк алюминия и условный массовый калькулятор.", "why": "Не выдавать массу металла в изделиях или доступный лом за фактический вторичный выход и не переносить энергозатраты одного материала на другой.", "evidence": [ "D19", "D20", "D21", "M10" ] }, { "date": "2026-09-14", "build": "NP176-I12", "what": "Год и EROI связаны только внутри одного из трёх выбранных опубликованных модельных маршрутов.", "why": "Устранить впечатление случайной независимости, не превращая учебную шкалу или исторический ряд ископаемого энергомикса в вымышленный прогноз.", "evidence": [ "D22", "M11" ] }, { "date": "2026-09-14", "build": "NP176-I13", "what": "Уточнено основание односторонней связи год→EROI; энергоёмкость переработки меди явно оставлена UNKNOWN; перечислены требования к воспроизводимому прогнозу.", "why": "Точно выполнить замечания независимой рецензии I12 без изменения траекторий и без автоматического повышения статусов.", "evidence": [ "own_i12_deepseek_review.txt", "eroi-scenario-pathways.json", "recycling-boundaries-data.json", "#milestones", "#recycling-limits" ] }, { "date": "2026-09-14", "build": "NP176-I14", "what": "Отозвана связь EROI электроэнергетики с общей шкалой; сценарный показатель отделён и снабжён долей электричества в конечном энергопотреблении.", "why": "EROI подсистемы, охватывающей около 21% мирового конечного энергопотребления, не представляет общий EROI энергетики.", "evidence": [ "D22", "D23", "M11", "#milestones" ] }, { "iteration": "I15", "change": "A falsification-first audit found D24 on PDF page 138, correcting the former blanket UNKNOWN for copper recycling energy. The source's 27/28 Mt internal discrepancy is now explicit. A complete scoped claim registry was added.", "why": "Scientific claims must survive source-level attempts at disproof; prior AI agreement and local tests did not reveal these source details.", "evidence": [ "D19", "D24", "claim-registry.json", "scientific-method-protocol.json" ] }, { "date": "2026-09-15", "version": "NP176-I16-local", "change": "Primary-stage row added from the same released dataset; observed slider now updates Primary, Final and Useful values together; no inverse EROI-to-year mapping.", "reason": "A single EROI value per year concealed incompatible energy-stage boundaries." }, { "date": "2026-09-15", "version": "NP176-I18-local", "change": "DeepSeek falsification review corrected the service model: the four rows are a partial demonstration basket; annual K_s is separated from continuous capability; required/N/A states, strict zero handling, vector and absolute deficits, and a dynamic EROI causal path were added.", "reason": "Annual allocated energy alone cannot establish firm capacity, timing, delivery or non-energy feasibility, and min(K_s) is only a Boolean all-required-rows test.", "evidence": [ "service-demand-model.json", "scenario-rules.json", "i17_deepseek_review.txt" ] }, { "version": "NP176-I20-local", "date": "2026-09-19", "summary": "Corrected inverse navigation on rounded pathways, preserved manual service overrides, aligned visible claim counts and model versions, and split methodology and service interpretation into dedicated pages.", "scientific_limits": [ "Displayed pathway nodes remain approximate Figure 2 digitisation rounded to 0.1.", "The service calculator remains an annual partial-basket test, not a continuity forecast." ] }, { "version": "NP176-I21-local", "date": "2026-09-19", "change": "Added a bounded quantitative technology example, UNECE life-cycle environmental cards, a dimensionless efficiency/rebound method, physical-money separation, systematic glossary links, and a visual marker for rounded flat scenario segments", "reason": "Independent DeepSeek I20 review: criteria 01, 16, 20, 29 and 30 failed; rounded plateau remained visually ambiguous" }, { "version": "NP176-I22-local", "date": "2026-09-19", "change": "Added a reproducibility page, cell-level provenance completion, source-vintage ledger, clustering sensitivity audit and literal term links in scoped visible prose.", "reason": "Resolve scientific acceptance criteria without converting missing evidence into PASS.", "remaining_unknown": [ "whole-energy forecast", "continuous reliability", "project deployment schedule" ] }, { "version": "NP176-I24-candidate", "date": "2026-09-20", "change": "Primary-source audit, full technical verification protocol, human usability protocol, owner/contact gate and reversible publication plan added without converting missing human or owner evidence into PASS.", "reason": "I24 closes locally provable gaps while retaining UNKNOWN where empirical evidence is absent.", "evidence": [ "primary-source-audit.json", "usability-test-protocol.json", "owner-contact-status.json", "release-manifest.json", "rollback-manifest.json" ] }, { "version": "NP176-I25-candidate", "date": "2026-09-20", "change": "Removed the contradictory 26/26 versus 8/41 source-verification statements, removed stale I23/I24 candidate labels, and separated proved public I24 from unpublished local I25.", "reason": "DeepSeek I24 criterion 10 FAIL was directly verified in audit.html; the publication section was also stale after the authorized I24 deploy/rollback drill.", "evidence": [ "i24_deepseek_review.txt SHA-256 0fc4f01946d52b5afeb4a025199632a7d59b5d013166fd99617e05347d20be83", "iteration24_publication_and_rollback_evidence.json" ], "scientific_scope": "No numerical data, model rule, EROI boundary or scenario trajectory changed." }, { "version": "NP176-I26-candidate", "date": "2026-09-20", "change": "Moved the scenario linkage directly below the 100→5 teaching scale and added bidirectional year and power-sector EROI sliders for all three displayed pathways.", "reason": "The owner required the year and EROI controls to visibly move together on the main page instead of relying on a separate deep page.", "evidence": [ "iteration26_technical_evidence/iteration26_linked_home_tests.json", "iteration26_technical_evidence/i26_linked_home_1440.png", "iteration26_technical_evidence/i26_linked_home_320.png" ], "scientific_scope": "The linkage is restricted to the published world power-sector pathways. The whole-energy 100→5 scale remains undated; no scenario point, EROI boundary or probability was changed." }, { "version": "NP176-I27-candidate", "date": "2026-09-22", "change": "Added complete visible boundary passports to the teaching scale, historical series, scenario pathways and technology inputs.", "reason": "DeepSeek I26 criterion 02 FAIL: not every displayed numerical EROI exposed numerator stage, denominator stage, cost composition, period and territory together.", "evidence": [ "i26_deepseek_review.txt SHA-256 408ab2e429ca79dbc0a8a46d9ad7fd6fbcb4de6bd6cfb9560c0f6d1854785617", "eroi-boundary-passports.json" ], "scientific_scope": "No EROI value or trajectory changed; source-supported included and excluded cost components were made visible." }, { "date": "2026-09-22", "build": "NP176-I28-candidate", "what": "Общеэнергетический EROI стал основным связанным показателем на главной, временной шкале и системной странице; электроэнергетическая модель вынесена в отдельное сравнение.", "why": "Не переносить EROI электроэнергетики на всю энергосистему и не скрывать диапазон сценарной неопределённости.", "evidence": [ "D28", "eroi-whole-energy-pathways.json", "timeline.html", "system.html", "power-timeline.html" ] }, { "date": "2026-09-22", "build": "NP176-FINAL-frozen", "what": "Согласованы видимая сводка 58/54/3/1, происхождение 28=27+1, маркировка страниц и неизменяемые контракты публикации и отката.", "why": "DeepSeek I28 criterion 07 FAIL and independent publication preflight found contradictory current-build metadata.", "evidence": [ "i28_deepseek_review.txt SHA-256 72ba6e8afe468d21fa0e6a292abdb3a8d3f9e85e75c25a9d5fbfde0b1c5c58b6", "final_consistency_fix_result.json" ], "scientific_scope": "Сценарные значения EROI, диапазоны, формулы и исходные данные не изменялись; исправлены только доказанные противоречия метаданных и релизная семантика." } ] }